THIS IS A leadership moment.
A tremendous opportunity lies before Gov. Mark Sanford -- a
chance to change everything. A chance to help us get off our
haunches and move forward, so that our state is no longer last where
it wants to be first, and first where it wants to be last. A chance
to make life in South Carolina everything that it should be, and
that the citizens of our beautiful state deserve for it to be.
It may not seem so. We're in the dog days of August. What news
there is either comes to us from far away, or is monotonous, or
depressing, or both. Take, for instance, the long-delayed lawsuit by
poor school districts claiming that the state doesn't meet its
obligation to fund them. Just more of the same sad story.
And yet there lies our opportunity.
Not in the lawsuit itself. Such things are not best settled in
courts. Should the districts "win," with the court ordering the
state to address the problem, we'll still be back where we were,
with the political branches having to figure out how to get the job
done. And if the districts lose -- well, I hardly want to think
about that. If the court decides the state is right, that it is
doing what it must to provide a "minimally adequate education,"
opponents of right action will seize upon it as proof that their
inertia is justified, and nothing needs to be done. And that would
be disastrous.
The biggest public policy issue in South Carolina is education.
And the education issue, properly understood, is about our failure
to provide equality of opportunity for all of our children to
realize their potential. Contrary to what some people believe, we do
know how to do schools in South Carolina. We have some excellent
ones -- in our affluent suburbs. It's out in the sleepy hamlets and
fields where our traditional roots lie, the places that the new
economy has forgotten, that levels of educational attainment lag so
far behind as to pull down the overall averages. And that makes the
whole state look -- to us and to outsiders -- like a place that no
one would want to invest in, and which the best and the brightest
will escape at the first opportunity.
So instead of standing by and watching this lawsuit be tried, we
need to get busy doing what we should have done long ago: Fix the
problem.
That may seem tough to do, what with our state's finances being
in such a mess. But in fact, that mess is in itself an opportunity.
In fact, it is one of a number of elements that come together to
provide us with the aforementioned leadership moment. Here are some
of those elements:
- The lawsuit itself, which is highlighting in detail the school
problem (as if we didn't already know about it).
- The legislative tax study committee, which is even now
examining how to overhaul the way we finance state government.
- The governor's ongoing budget hearings, in which he is
challenging a lot of the most fundamental assumptions regarding what
our taxes pay for and how we order our priorities.
- A vast restructuring of state government, one of the governor's
top goals, that is set to be at the top of the legislative agenda
when lawmakers return at the first of the year. This restructuring
would, among other things, put the state's portion of school
administration directly under the governor for the first time.
- The governor's emphasis on raising the average household
incomes of South Carolinians.
All of these things are inextricably tied together. You can't
improve education without addressing equality of opportunity. You
can't raise household incomes without raising the levels of
educational attainment. You can't finance any of it without trashing
our dysfunctional tax structure and starting over. You'll never
raise enough money, even with a revamped tax structure, without
rethinking the rest of government and making it more efficient and
effective. And with half of the state's resources going to schools
already, it's hard to imagine us making much more progress without
making education the direct responsibility of the governor.
That last bit is not to say that progress has not been made under
the current system. During the tenure of state Superintendent Inez
Tenenbaum, schoolchildren have been doing demonstrably better in a
variety of ways. Of course, all that has been threatened by the
current funding cutbacks, and Mrs. Tenenbaum has shown great
political courage in telling lawmakers in no uncertain terms that we
cannot and must not slide backwards.
But the pulpit of a separately elected superintendent of
education will never be bully enough to overcome the forces of
resistance.
A job like this calls for a governor. The Legislature is made up
of 170 people with competing aims, and many of its most powerful
members come from districts that provide them with little motivation
to help the poorest parts of the state catch up.
It has to be the governor. And in many ways, this leadership
moment was made for Mark Sanford. He doesn't mind taking political
risks. He delights in shaking things up. He is passionate about
improving our economy. He has the ability to see how all of it --
schools, taxes, restructuring, economic development -- fit
together.
What he needs to do -- what we, the people of South Carolina,
need him to do -- is sketch a vision for addressing it all, and then
paint that vision in colors bright enough to overcome any remaining
tendency of lawmakers to cling to gray stagnation.
In the next few months, he has a narrow window in which to act,
in which to pull together the various elements of this opportunity
into a coherent whole. He must do so.