An attorney for the Catawba Indian tribe said Tuesday the tribe
might sue the state of South Carolina and introduce video poker
machines on its York County reservation if it is not allowed to set
up a federally approved bingo operation near I-95.
"The tribe will explore all its options, including legal action,
to get back to its status in 1993, when it was the lead gaming
operation in South Carolina," said attorney Jay Bender.
Bender's remarks represent a serious escalation of the Catawbas'
mostly behind-the-scenes efforts to launch high-jackpot bingo in
Orangeburg County.
Under a 1993 agreement made with the state and federal
governments, the Catawbas run a low-stakes bingo operation in York
County. They need congressional approval to move to a more
sophisticated, higher-payoff bingo.
In Santee, in southern Orangeburg County, the Catawbas believe
they have found a desirable location because of the thousands of
cars that pass daily near the intersection of I-95 and I-26. The
Catawbas need federal legislation to allow them to electronically
link Santee bingo operations to those of other Indian tribes. That
way, they could offer jackpots of more than $100,000.
So far, the Catawbas' efforts have stalled in the U.S. Senate,
largely because of opposition by U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C. He
fears the Catawbas might use any congressional approval for a
higher-stakes bingo operation to move toward hard-core casino-type
gambling like blackjack and slot machines.
In the Senate, one senator can in most circumstances block a
bill. So although Sen. Fritz Hollings, D-S.C., favors the Catawba
bingo expansion, Graham's lone opposition is likely to kill it.
Graham said Tuesday he believes it is likely the Catawbas will
file a lawsuit against South Carolina if they can't get Congress to
pass a law allowing them to link their bingo operations to those in
other states.
"You don't have to be a rocket scientist to figure this is going
to go to court eventually if something's not resolved," Graham
said.
The senator called the situation a "mess" and indicated the state
might be vulnerable to such a lawsuit. He questioned the 1993
agreement the state made with the Catawbas, and wondered aloud
whether it could stand legal scrutiny.
"The day we got in the lottery business, we became a competitor
(of the Catawbas). We got no one to blame in South Carolina but
ourselves," Graham said.
Under the 1993 agreement, the Catawbas claim, they -- not the
state -- are supposed to be South Carolina's leading gambling
business. But competition from the state-operated lottery, which
began in January 2002, has cut their Rock Hill bingo revenues in
half, Bender said. In 2001, before the lottery, the tribe earned
$1.9 million. But in 2002, in competition with the lottery, the
tribe earned only $911,000, he said.
Graham also said it is "settled federal law" that Indians can
engage in any form of gambling permitted under state law.
"So the Indians could go into the lottery business if they wanted
to," said Graham, an attorney.
Graham said his first goal is to prevent the Catawbas from going
into "the casino business" -- meaning the operation of a Las
Vegas-style casino offering slot machines and such games as
blackjack and roulette.
Graham said he would listen to the wishes of Gov. Mark Sanford
and state lawmakers, many of whom oppose the Catawbas' expansion
plans.
"I am not going to vote for any federal statute until there's a
consensus at home as to what is the best course to deal with the
Indian gaming problem," Graham said.
"And in fairness to the Catawbas, the state of South Carolina
created this mess," he said, referring to the state's decision to
allow the Catawbas to go into the gambling business.
"Things come back to bite you."
The Catawbas have promised that if they get congressional
approval to offer high-stakes bingo games in Santee, they won't try
to set up a Las Vegas-style casino anywhere in South Carolina.
The Catawbas originally filed suit in 1980, seeking compensation
for 144,000 acres they claimed South Carolina stole from them in
1840. In 1993, the state settled the claim by agreeing to pay the
Catawbas $12.5 million and to let the tribe set up two limited bingo
operations. Bingo games were supposed to assure the tribe a steady
income.
Bender now says that agreement also would allow the Catawbas to
operate video poker machines.
A Columbia attorney, Bender specializes in media law and First
Amendment issues. Among his clients are The State newspaper and the
S.C. Press Association.
Meanwhile, representatives of the Southern Baptist Convention and
the United Methodists plan a press conference today at the State
House to speak against the Catawbas' plans in Santee.
S.C. House Speaker David Wilkins, R-Greenville, will be on
hand.