Since money,
services don’t grow on trees, let’s consider tax
reform
By WARREN BOLTON Associate Editor
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS are scurrying this year more than ever to find
ways to pay for services and keep property taxes in check.
• Richland County Council, which
approved a budget for the fiscal year that begins Thursday that will
require increases in property taxes, is considering asking voters to
approve a 1 percent sales tax increase in November. The idea is to
use the revenue to reduce property taxes.
• The town of Lexington wants to
pay for projects with its food tax that would lock it in for 10
years.
• Lexington County voters will
consider a 1 percent sales tax increase in November that would pay
for school construction.
The reason for all the maneuvering is to address concerns about
rising property taxes, the most hated of all taxes. Rising costs for
schools and other services as well as bad budgeting on the part of
state officials have put unprecedented burdens on property taxes.
Homeowners also are feeling the pinch as counties struggle to
replace dollars lost due to a reduction in the assessment on
vehicles and the property tax relief act of 1995.
Add to that the fact that so many politicians run for office
today pledging they will not raise taxes or that they will reduce
taxes, and we’ve got a mess.
Of course, those who make those promises don’t tell the rest of
the story. What will they cut or reduce to make ends meet? Some
candidates vow to end waste and abuse, but it’s rare that they
produce any real savings.
The truth is we need comprehensive tax reform in our state, and
the result won’t necessarily be a drop in our overall tax burden.
Some taxes, perhaps even property taxes, could go down. Others
could, and should, rise.
The other thing we need in our state — and on the local level —
is a dose of reality. Services cost money. The stable revenue from
property taxes is key to providing those funds. While we can and
should craft a system that works in the best interest of all
taxpayers, we still depend on government to deliver certain
services.
I know. Money doesn’t grow on trees. But neither do roads, water,
sewer, garbage, schools, health departments and jails. Nor do
schools, libraries, courthouses, parks, cars and trucks, teachers,
principals, police officers, prison and jail guards, firefighters
and engineers. Someone has to pay for these things. That somebody is
us — the taxpayers.
Lexington County is grappling with the issue about as much as
anyone these days. During its recent budget debate, the council had
to acknowledge the county has needs that require higher taxes. It
got lots of input from residents on all sides of the issue.
Lexington, one of the state’s fastest-growing and richest
counties, has its share of tax relief advocates. But the growth of
the county has some residents and departments asking for more and
improved services.
The requests included increases to library operations and new
library construction, recreation operations and new services, and
new employees in the solicitor’s office.
Meeting demand for increased services — from more schools to more
deputies — is going to be an ongoing challenge as more people move
into the county.
It’s a battle being fought in other locales as well. It is taking
place in an environment in which many people seem to want services
without paying sufficient taxes. Even some who support comprehensive
tax reform do so in the hope of finding some magical — or should I
say mythical — relief.
But we’ve learned magic bullets don’t exist. When the Legislature
instituted the 1995 rollback, homeowners were looking for an awesome
break. Initially, the state fully reimbursed counties for rolling
back school operations costs on the first $100,000 of assessed value
on homes. But the cost spiraled, and the Legislature froze the
amount it sends back to some counties, while still requiring the
same rollback. Counties are now raising taxes on some residents in
order to keep giving the tax relief.
No matter the scheme, we’ve got to pay. We should ditch the
schemes and piecemeal changes that only make matters worse. Our
state and local tax system is a hodgepodge of exemptions.
We need to devise a well-thought-out, sensible and — above all —
realistic solution. It’s not realistic to think we can reduce taxes
willy-nilly and keep up with growing service demands. We must decide
how best to distribute the tax burden among various types of taxes
and groups of people. We need a fair tax code that is easy to
understand and manage. It must rest on a dependable revenue stream
that can withstand economic changes.
Otherwise, we will continue to see local governments and school
districts looking for dollars and dimes under rocks or withholding
needed services.
While Columbia City Council approved a budget for next fiscal
year that won’t require city taxes to increase, officials predict
that if more money isn’t found, services will have to be slashed in
2005-06.
The city is looking for more money, be it through applying for
grants, increasing transfers from the water and sewer fund or other
means. One thing is for sure, Mayor Bob Coble said: “No one is going
to be for a tax increase.”
Tax reform, anyone?
Reach Mr. Bolton at (803) 771-8631 or wbolton@thestate.com. |