Letters show
Thurmond kept tabs on favors, eyes on political
returns
By JOHN MONK News Columnist
In 1955, after winning the U.S. Senate seat he would hold for 48
years, Thurmond wrote a four-page memo to his Senate staff
instructing them about how to handle visiting constituents.
“Let Senator know when any South Carolinians come into office,”
it read in part. Also, the memo said, “Give every adult South
Carolinian a large picture of the Senator and every South Carolina
child a small picture.”
Attention to personal networks, including constituents, played a
vital role in Thurmond’s climb from state senator to judge to
governor to U.S. senator.
Constituents were the most visible of the many networks Thurmond
cultivated over the years. Others were less visible to the
public.
All Thurmond’s networks, public and private, had two goals —
electing him and keeping him in office.
However, newly discovered records show that, when it came to his
networks, Thurmond was far more secretive and methodical than has
been known. Those records also show Thurmond kept tabs on those he
helped so he could target their assistance at election time.
The invisible networks included a secret army of “colonels,”
Clemson grads, intellectuals, former jurors in courts where Thurmond
had been a judge, barbers, politicians, staffers, family members and
ordinary citizens.
“He always thought in those terms — organizations and networks
and contacts,” said Neal Thigpen, a longtime Thurmond watcher and
Francis Marion University political science professor.
In Clemson University’s Special Collections unit, about 4 million
of an estimated 8 million Thurmond’s papers — mostly letters to and
from the senator — are available to the public. The State this year
reviewed thousands of his letters from 1920-2002, Thurmond’s last
full year in office. He died in 2003 at the age of 100.
Thurmond’s networks are among his most significant
achievements.
Although he served 48 years in the U.S. Senate, Thurmond was not
known for passing major legislation — unless you count a law he
sponsored concerning wine labels. Neither did he succeed in blocking
civil rights legislation — his major goal for 15 years.
Instead, the one area in which Thurmond excelled was networking,
including constituent services.
From his earliest days in public life, Thurmond connected with
thousands of people, stroking their egos, doing them favors, helping
them get scholarships and jobs.
In the Clemson letters, Thurmond flatters, praises, remembers
birthdays, promises football tickets, sends gifts, name-drops, and
offers sympathy for deaths and congratulations for achievements.
His networks proved so strong that in 1996, Thurmond, slowed by
age, won re-election again to the U.S. Senate at age 93. No
well-known candidate challenged him, largely because he had shaped
the careers of virtually every top Republican in South Carolina and
done favors for many Democrats.
In that last race, Thurmond continued to tap old networks,
calling politicians and friends — or their sons and daughters.
“He knew money and media had become the dominant part of
campaigns, but he still enjoyed doing the things that had gotten him
where he was,” said Tony Denny, Thurmond’s 1996 campaign
manager.
BRED FOR POWER
Thurmond was bred for power from boyhood.
His father, lawyer Will Thurmond of Edgefield, was close to U.S.
Sen. Ben Tillman, the state’s most powerful politician from 1890
until his death in 1918.
Will Thurmond introduced young Strom to Tillman and took his son
to trials, political debates and the Legislature. He sent Strom to
Clemson and taught him to be a lawyer.
One of Thurmond’s first known networking efforts came in
1930.
Only 27 and a first-year lawyer, Thurmond was asked to manage the
campaign of a S.C. Supreme Court associate justice for the chief
justice’s job. In judicial races, candidates lobby members of the
Legislature, seeking their “pledges” of support. Rounding up pledges
requires gamesmanship and an ability to size people up.
Newly discovered letters between Thurmond and Eugene Blease, the
candidate for chief justice, show Thurmond played an active role in
getting Blease elected.
Thurmond visited lawmakers in their home counties and helped
Blease keep tabs on how many solid pledges he had.
Blease won, 134-32.
“You certainly ... contributed greatly to the victory,” Blease
wrote Thurmond.
STATE SENATE
In 1932, Thurmond won election to the S.C. Senate.
There, Thurmond cultivated officials above and below him.
In November 1934, for example, he wrote then-Gov. I.C. Blackwood.
“I noticed in the paper that Wednesday, Nov. 21st, was your
birthday, and I am writing to extend congratulations. ... I hope
that you will have many more birthdays. ... Just as a little
reminder of my friendship for you, I am sending you under separate
cover a box of cigars.”
That letter was a sign of things to come. Over the next 68 years,
Thurmond would write thousands of letters congratulating people —
from the high and the mighty to the low and obscure — on their
birthdays and other special occasions.
Thurmond also sought to establish himself as a mentor to less
senior senators.
“I know that you will make a splendid Senator and I shall
anticipate with pleasure serving in the Senate with you,” Thurmond
wrote on Sept. 10, 1934, to M.A. Shuler of Kingstree. At the time,
Thurmond had been a senator only two years.
While serving as a state senator, Thurmond also was named to the
board of trustees of Winthrop College, a state-supported women’s
college in York County.
Winthrop students began to turn to Thurmond for help with jobs
and scholarships. In scores of cases, he wrote letters to assist
them.
FROM JUDGE TO GOVERNOR
Even after he was elected a judge by the Legislature in 1938,
Thurmond continued to nourish his ties with Winthrop.
In a Feb. 28, 1939, letter to Winthrop president Shelton Phelps,
for example, Thurmond mentioned he had read recently where Bernard
Baruch, a noted financier, had donated $10,000 to S.C. colleges for
scholarships.
“I have been thinking recently of establishing 10 $100 loan
scholarships for Juniors and Seniors in the Home Economics
Department at Winthrop,” Thurmond wrote.
Thurmond’s offer was accepted.
In 1946, Thurmond — still a judge — decided to run for governor.
Keeping his decision secret, he began to tap old networks.
Thurmond, a Clemson grad, contacted a friend at the Clemson
alumni association, asking for alumni names and addresses.
On Feb. 27, 1946, Clemson alumni officer Jake Woodward forwarded
roughly 4,000 names to Thurmond. “Of course it is needless for me to
caution you about this list, as we at the College are not supposed
to take a hand in politics,” Woodward wrote.
Thurmond replied, “Any information that you think to pass on to
me any time, will be kept confidential.”
Thurmond also wrote officials with state and civic groups, asking
for membership lists. In this way, he tapped into the state’s
800-plus “white” barbers. He also got the names of most state
doctors, lawyers, Lions Club members, Winthrop graduates,
magistrates and county officers.
As the campaign went on, Thurmond resigned his judgeship and
began contacting jurors, to whom he had made speeches as a
judge.
On May 30, 1946, he wrote R. O. Ward, Williamsburg County’s clerk
of courts, saying, “I would like to have a list of the petit jurors
and grand jurors who served at the different terms of court over
which I presided since January 1938, the date I went on the
bench.”
Ward sent the names, telling Thurmond there was “no charge.”
Other clerks obliged, as well.
Thurmond also began to assemble a brain trust.
On March 6, 1946, he wrote an old friend, B.O. Williams, head of
the University of Georgia’s sociology department, asking him to
forward talking points for him to run on.
It was a process Thurmond would use repeatedly in coming years —
quietly assembling counselors to advise him on policy.
Over the years, those counselors would include Robert Figg, an
active segregationist lawyer and later dean of the University of
South Carolina law school, and Walter Brown, a Spartanburg County
broadcaster.
SECRET ‘COLONELS’
After being sworn in as governor in early 1947, Thurmond began to
bestow the title of “colonel” to hundreds of friends and political
allies. Thurmond would summon the honoree to his office, pronounce
him a colonel and hand him a certificate.
“It was sort of a political reward,” recalled former state
Supreme Court Chief Justice Bruce Littlejohn, 91, one of the last
surviving colonels.
Some colonels’ titles were bestowed for achievements, similar to
the Order of the Palmetto award that S.C. governors hand out today.
But many of Thurmond’s colonels were foot soldiers in his personal
political army, expected to work in his campaigns.
Thurmond wanted to keep their names secret. “We do not desire to
give the appointments to the newspapers if it can be avoided,”
Thurmond wrote in a 1947 letter to Littlejohn, then speaker of the
S.C. House.
In 1948, as Thurmond readied for a bid for the U.S. presidency,
he used his colonels to influence the state Democratic
convention.
“I should like to see as many as possible of my Colonels’ elected
delegates to the State Convention,” Thurmond wrote on April 20,
1948, to Fred Pearman, an Anderson businessman who recruited other
colonels.
In 1949, two state representatives publicly pressed Thurmond to
say who his colonels were. If Thurmond was using taxpayer money to
“engrave the fancy certificates,” the citizens had a right to know
who the colonels were, argued state Rep. John Bolt Culbertson of
Greenville.
Thurmond refused, saying the lawmakers were “sticking their noses
into something that does not concern them.”
Today, the names of more than 800 Thurmond colonels are at
Clemson, along with letters spelling out the political roles some
were to play.
‘LEARN THE SENATOR’S SIGNATURE’
After his election to the U.S. Senate in 1954, Thurmond left
little to chance in dealing with his ultimate network — voters.
Over the years, Thurmond sent thousands of letters on every
conceivable subject to S.C. residents.
In a January 1959 memo to top aide Harry Dent, Thurmond
instructed his staff to review S.C. newspapers and clip
“congratulatory matters such as persons who have been married for
25, 50 years, etc.,” and “articles that will give us an index as to
what is occurring in the particular community where the newspaper is
published and the viewpoint of the people there on any particular
subject.”
Thurmond would write anyone for anything.
“Dear Principal,” began a form letter he sent out on Feb. 25,
1971. “Would you please forward to my Washington Office as soon as
possible a list of your graduating seniors. ... It will be my
pleasure to furnish each graduate with a certificate for having
achieved this milestone in his or her education.”
Thurmond didn’t have time to sign the hundreds of letters going
out each week under his name. So some staffers signed his signature,
a common Senate practice.
Even that solution wasn’t enough.
A July 22, 1977, a Thurmond office memo says that because “of the
undue strain put on those few girls who are authorized to sign the
Senator’s correspondence, it has been decided that each secretary
should learn the Senator’s signature. ... Please try to have the
Senator’s signature mastered by next Friday, July 29.”
‘STROM THURMOND ALUMNI ASSOCIATION’
Over the years, tens of thousands of people wrote Thurmond for
help with everything from Social Security to passport problems. Each
got a prompt signed reply, saying the senator or his staff would do
what they could.
Documents at Clemson make it clear Thurmond kept tabs on those he
helped, expecting their support in return.
For example, while gearing up for his 1972 re-election bid,
Thurmond sent political operative Sterling Anderson into S.C.
counties. Anderson contacted movers and shakers, making notes on
their businesses and their families that he forwarded to
Thurmond.
In one case, Anderson wrote he had contacted Edward Khoury,
treasurer of Morrison Textile Machinery Co. in Fort Lawn. Anderson
noted Thurmond had helped the company win a contract with a South
Vietnamese firm. “They are very happy about the Senator’s
effectiveness,” Anderson wrote, adding, “They want to help the
Senator in his campaign.”
As a senator, Thurmond also hired hundreds for his Senate or
political staffs over the years. Many went on to higher offices.
There, among other things, they helped Thurmond stay in office.
Thurmond’s Washington staff alums include Attorney General Henry
McMaster, former Gov. David Beasley, the late political operative
Lee Atwater, former U.S. Rep. John Napier, S.C. Court of Appeals
Judge Sam Stillwell, and U.S. Court of Appeals Judge Billy Wilkins,
brother of S.C. House Speaker David Wilkins.
These former staffers — along with hundreds less prominent —
formed what was informally known as the “Strom Thurmond Alumni
Association.”
Its members were located across South Carolina. “They provided a
pretty good base for the campaign,” Denny said.
‘A LEGEND IN YOUR OWN TIME’
After 1970, when new federal laws allowed blacks to vote in
significant numbers, Thurmond began to tap into black networks.
In early 1971, Thurmond hired one of the state’s foremost black
activists, the late Tom Moss of the NAACP.
Moss began giving Thurmond intelligence reports on blacks. In
1973, for example, Moss attended a meeting of S.C. black mayors and
wrote Thurmond a memo.
On July 10, 1973, Thurmond replied to Moss, “I have written to
each of the Mayors listed in your report and offered to assist with
their problems.”
A sample Thurmond follow-up letter went to Mayor Charles Ross of
Lincolnville, in Charleston County. Thurmond wrote, “I just wanted
you to know that I stand ready to help you with your housing and
water problems.”
Thurmond also made grand gestures to blacks. In September 1983,
Thurmond — the one-time — invited a black South Carolinian to dine
with the president.
“It was a pleasure to have you as my special guest at the dinner
with President Reagan in Columbia,” Thurmond wrote Luns C.
Richardson, president of Morris College in Sumter.
Thurmond impressed Richardson, who wrote that being with Reagan
and Thurmond “was one of the high points” of his life. “You are
indeed a legend in your own time — a man of rare and unusual
foresight ... courage, commitment and patriotism.”
In an interview last week, Richardson — still president at Morris
— said the meeting with Reagan remains a high point.
Thurmond was a longtime Morris friend, channeling at least $5
million in federal grants and loans to the college, Richardson
said.
“I never had a problem voting for him because he didn’t have a
problem doing things for us,” he said.
On occasion, Thurmond also could get tough with supporters.
In November 1972, a longtime political backer, Jim Howey of
Lancaster, wrote Thurmond seeking reimbursement of $2,000 that Howey
said he had spent to help Thurmond win re-election that fall. “I
went all over the county for you and worked hard,” Howey wrote.
Thurmond refused, telling Howey no one had promised to pay
him.
“ ... you will remember that I have had your sons up here as
Senate Pages and that I chose Bill over many others for the
appointment to the Naval Academy which is equivalent to a $50,000
education,” Thurmond wrote on Dec. 14, 1972. “Recently, I
recommended Robert to the Vice President for consideration for an
appointment to the academy also.”
NETWORKS DO HOMAGE
Thurmond’s networks not only voted for him — they paid
tribute.
Over the years, his supporters named buildings, streets and
schools after him. In 1999, supporters — led by state Sen. John
Courson, R-Richland — erected a larger-than-life statue of Thurmond
on the State House grounds.
Thurmond also secured a living monument to his family’s political
heritage — a next generation.
Will Thurmond died in 1934, having helped launch his son’s
career. Similarly, Strom Thurmond in 2002, his last year in office,
used his power to get his son, Strom Jr., named U.S. attorney for
South Carolina.
Strom Jr., 29, didn’t have much experience for the prestigious
post, which paid $118,400 a year.
But he got the job. Even Democrats said Strom Jr. has acquitted
himself well in the job, which he will resign in January to practice
law in Aiken.
Thurmond’s network had come full circle.
Eileen Waddell also contributed to this story. Reach Monk at
(803) 771-8344 or jmonk@thestate.com. |