When the other girls at S.C. State College were wearing bobby
socks and saddle shoes, Essie Mae Washington-Williams was in hose
and heels.
Friends then and now describe her as poised and charming — a
class treasurer who married a member of S.C. State’s first law
school class.
“She seemed a little more mature than the rest of us,” said
Thelma Little of Brooklyn, N.Y., S.C. State class of 1947.
She was private. She did not gossip.
She now says she had a secret.
It was widely rumored that the late U.S. Sen. Strom Thurmond,
white and an ardent segregationist, had a biracial? daughter.
It also was widely rumored that the daughter was Williams, but
she never acknowledged it, and even close friends and neighbors
didn’t ask.
Her children and grandchildren say they have known for “a while”
now.
“But like her, we’ve kept quiet for the most part,” said Dr.
Ronald James Williams, her son. “It was best overall for
everybody.”
But today, at an 11 a.m. press conference at the Adam’s Mark
hotel in downtown Columbia, Williams will tell her story.
At age 78, she is Thurmond’s oldest child, a claim his family
acknowledged Monday.
Williams says she is telling her story out of duty to history and
out of respect for her own family, so they will know their
heritage.
She has friends in South Carolina, where she was born and where
she went to college. Some, like Lewie Roache, may come to today’s
press conference.
“I’d love to see Essie,” said Roache, a classmate who later
became dean of the School of Arts and Sciences at S.C. State.
QUIET AND RESERVED
Williams lives now in Los Angeles, where she taught school until
she retired.
Her friends here and there are protective of her. When asked
about her, their responses follow two lines:
She is a quiet and reserved woman, who is setting the record
straight.
And she is no different from thousands of other blacks with white
fathers, who have carried their secrets for too long.
“Why all the hullabaloo about Essie?” asked Thelma Little, a
friend and a 1947 graduate of S.C. State. “Everybody’s going on,
like they don’t believe it. Well, why not?”
White men have been having children by black women for centuries,
she said.
“You look at African-Americans, none of them look like any of the
first 20 that came off the boat,” Little said. “Some people talk
about it and some don’t.”
The difference is that Williams is the daughter of perhaps the
last century’s most noted segregationist. Thurmond ran for president
as a Dixiecrat in 1948, when his daughter was in college.
That hypocrisy makes the story noteworthy, said another former
classmate, Theodore K. Sims, class of 1948.
Sims was walking with friends at a Detroit shopping mall on
Tuesday morning. He said one of the other retirees summed it up this
way:
“He said, ‘Thurmond was a segregationist politically but an
integrationist sexually.’ I thought that was an accurate
description.”
REGULAR VISITS
Williams was born Oct. 12, 1925. Her mother, Carrie Butler, was a
16-year-old maid in the Thurmond home in Edgefield.
Strom Thurmond was a 22-year-old teacher and coach when Carrie
Butler gave birth. A relative took the child to Coatesville, Pa., to
be raised by family.
After graduating from high school, Williams briefly studied
nursing in Harlem Hospital in New York City. She left there just
after Thurmond was elected governor and enrolled in S.C. State in
Orangeburg.
Thurmond began visiting the campus regularly. Students and
faculty would clear out of Wilkinson Hall, which then housed the
administrative offices and the library.
Thurmond would arrive in a limousine and spend 45 minutes to an
hour in Wilkinson. Some students said they thought he was meeting
with the president. But as the visits continued, it was rumored
Thurmond was visiting his daughter.
Williams did not talk about her father. And during that time, no
one would have asked.
“In 1948, you didn’t spread that rumor too much because of the
political situation,” Sims said.
The state was segregated then.
Black students could not attend white schools, such as Clemson
University or the University of South Carolina. On vacation, black
students could not swim at Myrtle Beach. They were kept out by a
rope in the ocean.
“If you floated across the rope, you could be arrested,” Sims
said. “You look back and think that’s impossible, but it really
happened.”
In college, Williams met Julius Williams, one of eight students
in S.C. State’s first law school class.
They married and moved to Savannah in the 1950s. Julius Williams
died in 1964, at 45.
‘AN INSPIRATION’
Later that year, Williams and her children — two daughters and
two sons — moved to California.
They were one of the first families to integrate View Park, a Los
Angeles neighborhood of palm trees, pastel bungalows and
close-clipped lawns.
Williams began life anew in a city that, for tens of thousands of
blacks at the time, promised steady employment and relative
tolerance.
“We were the first blacks to move on to the block,” said retired
probation officer Melvin Arterberry Sr. “They were the second.”
Williams still lives there today, in a soft pink stucco house.
Built just after World War II, the house is located in southwest Los
Angeles and would be worth about $400,000, an area real estate agent
estimated.
Pink gates and window bars secure an in-ground backyard pool,
long enough for a short lap. They also guard a cream-colored Lexus
in the driveway. The property smells of orange trees.
It is a neighborhood of teachers and insurance salesmen, mostly
African-American, seven miles from the Pacific Ocean.
There, Williams is one of the grand ladies of the community,
revered as a widow who loved and provided for her children while
working for the betterment of other young people.
She went back to school and earned a master’s degree in education
in 1972, from the University of Southern California.
“I’ve always known her as a parent, educator and strong community
member,” said Fahamisha Butler, who lives across the street and went
to school with the Williams children.
“She is remarkable. She raised those children by herself. She was
a teacher. I’m a teacher. I train teachers at UCLA. She was an
inspiration to me.”
She is a humble inspiration though, said Earl Ofari Hutchinson, a
Los Angeles author and radio host whose son married one of Williams’
granddaughters.
“She’s a quiet person, a very thoughtful person, someone who
thinks things through,” he said.
He also describes her as “politically aware” and “socially
progressive.”
For many years, he said, she was active in a church led by the
Rev. Madison Shockley, who is known for his social work.
PERSISTENT RUMORS
Like many who know Williams, Hutchinson had heard and read
stories alleging that Thurmond was her father. But she never talked
about it, and friends were too polite to ask.
Hutchinson said he didn’t know whether the rumors were true until
last summer, when a family member told him Williams was considering
a public declaration of her connection to Thurmond.
This week, he said, some blacks in Los Angeles have been critical
of her for waiting so long.
“They say she should have come out and slammed the guy to expose
him as a racist hypocrite.”
But those who know Williams say they understand why she held her
tongue. Both she and Thurmond, for decades, denied they were father
and daughter, instead calling each other “family friends.”
“He was still family,” said Hutchinson. “And she didn’t want to
do anything to harm her father.”
“I could see why she couldn’t say anything; that was appropriate
at the time,” said Arterberry, who has lived across the street from
Williams for nearly 40 years. Arterberry never talked to her about
Thurmond, though he has long believed the former senator was her
father.
Perhaps something good will come of this, Roache said, if people
become more aware of S.C. State University and how the state is not
meeting its needs — ignoring its historically black flagship school,
letting historic buildings crumble, the library go without supplies
and other infrastructure fall apart.
“I hate to say it, but we still got a long way to go,” Roache
said.
RIGHTING THE RECORD
In South Carolina, some black leaders hope some good will come of
this, especially if mixed heritage becomes easier and more
acceptable to talk about.
“It’s one of those things that aren’t talked about that really
should be talked about,” said state Sen. Clementa Pinckney,
D-Jasper.
Some of Thurmond’s political proteges have questioned the timing
of Williams’ coming forward, since Thurmond died June 26 and cannot
address her claim.
But Pinckney said it is proper to correct the record.
He credits the Thurmond children with acknowledging their
half-sister. He also credits Thurmond for helping Williams
financially over the years, even though they both only said they
were family friends.
“He took care of his daughter. He sent her to school and he
helped her,” Pinckney said. “You have to respect that.”
Reach Bauerlein at (803) 771-8485 or vbauerlein@thestate.com
Reach Markoe at (202) 383-6023 or lmarkoe@krwashington.com
Staff writers Aaron Gould Sheinin and Jennifer Talhelm
contributed to this
report.