Shaw AFB closure
would be 'cataclysmic' blow to Midlands' economy
SUSANNE M.
SCHAFER Associated
Press
SUMTER, S.C. - South Carolina officials are
scrambling to keep Shaw Air Force Base out of target range as the
Pentagon draws up its largest-ever base closure list for 2005.
If Shaw is slated for closure, the loss of some 6,800 civilian
and military jobs and the base's $230 million annual payroll would
deal a knockout blow to the heart of this economically strapped
state, says Gov. Mark Sanford.
"I'd trade nearly anything off to protect Shaw because - unlike
other parts of South Carolina - if Shaw goes, you're talking a
cataclysmic economic event in Sumter County," Sanford said in a
recent AP interview. "Shaw is in a dangerous spot."
Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld has said he would like to see
about a fourth of the military's more than 400 installations shut
down to help streamline the military and shift scarce dollars from
supporting surplus real estate to new weapons and other uses.
Also, the Air Force is looking at a plan to reduce the number of
fighter jets, which could put Shaw in jeopardy, said defense analyst
Loren Thompson with the Lexington Institute think tank in Arlington,
Va.
Shaw is home to the 20th Fighter Wing, which is composed of three
F-16CJ fighter squadrons. The aircraft were on the forefront of the
recent conflict in Iraq, but they could be shifted to other
sites.
"There are a number of bases in the Southeast that are capable of
hosting those fighting forces," Thompson said.
Shaw is headquarters for the 9th Air Force and the U.S. Central
Command Air Forces, units that played key roles in Iraq and
Afghanistan. However, hundreds of servicemen and women in those
units worked out of an air base in Saudi Arabia during those
conflicts, evidence they could be based nearly anywhere in this age
of high-tech computers and communications.
Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., said he is making the argument that
Shaw, its aircraft and its personnel are vital to the defense of the
nation in the 21st century - the primary criterion the Pentagon is
supposed to use in deciding whether an installation should stay or
go.
"I make the case for bases in South Carolina on their military
merit alone," Graham said. "The past performance of these bases
during recent conflicts shows they deserve continued use. They are
indispensable to our defense."
He said Shaw offers high-quality training ranges for pilots and
is not challenged by encroaching suburban growth like some bases
along the East Coast.
Those points that will work in Shaw's favor, Thompson said,
adding that it is possible the Air Force could shift aircraft to
Shaw from other locations.
Retired Air Force Maj. Gen. Tom Olsen, executive director of the
Sumter Base Defense Committee, said the community "desperately wants
to retain all that military presence" in central South Carolina.
Of the 106,000 people in the county, he said about 25,000 "depend
upon Shaw in some form or another" for their livelihood.
The 5,600 active duty men and women connected with the base have
about 12,000 family members. Sixty percent of those military
families "choose to live in the local community," said Olsen,
himself a former Shaw commander.
There are about 2,000 civilians in the county who work at Shaw,
making it "a big source of employment for the local economy," said
Grier Blackwelder of the Sumter City Chamber of Commerce.
Blackwelder said the community has some diversified industries
including the local Caterpillar plant, three furniture companies, a
maker of pharmaceutical supplies and several tool and automotive
parts plants.
But the questions about Shaw's future inject "a feeling of
uncertainty" into the community, he said.
Across the state, the military conducts $5.6 billion in sales
with South Carolina businesses, according to a recent study
conducted by Donald Schunk of the University of South Carolina. Shaw
contributes $261 million annually to that number, Schunk found.
While the governor voiced concern about the negative effect of a
Shaw closure within the state, he argued it would add to federal red
ink as well. A closure "`would cause unemployment to go up, a whole
variety of social welfare (costs) to go up," Sanford said.
And compared with the Charleston or Beaufort areas where other
military bases are located, "there are no other economic cylinders"
that could help the Midlands region rebound from a Shaw closure,
Sanford said.
"The economic impact of a closure would be devastating, but we
can't make the argument for Shaw based on economic welfare to the
state. I argue that Shaw is vital to the vision of our nation's
military in the coming century," said Graham, a member of the Senate
Armed Services Committee.
He said he called Air Force Chief of Staff Gen. John Jumper, the
No. 1 general in the Air Force who was once based at Shaw, and
Secretary John Roche, the Air Force's top civilian, to his office to
make that case. "I can assure you, they know how I feel," Graham
said. |