'In the long run, I think we will be
OK. There are a lot of things people are working on that will help
fill the void [if the plant closes].'
Ed Powell | president, Weirton (W.Va.) Area
Chamber of Commerce
Finding an economic driver as strong as steel is straining
Georgetown and other steel towns across the country.
Long dependent on steel's jobs and economic investment, the towns
are praying for their plants to pull through the tough times while
working to find something that could help fill the void if rumors of
mill closings become reality.
"It's devastating to the whole area," said Weirton, W.Va., Mayor
Bill Miller, whose town shares the name of its steel mill, which is
trying to hang on like Georgetown and other plants. "It's like
having part of you kind of cut off."
Weirton is turning to tourism. Bartonville, Ill., is hoping
growth in stores and roads will lure more development. Both have
relied on steel since their beginnings and are facing uncer-
tain
futures, as is Georgetown.
"The future of Georgetown does not lie in manufacturing," said Al
Parish, an economist with Charleston Southern University. "It's
simply going to have to alter itself. It's doing well with tourism.
It's going to have to attract retirees and the health care
businesses that cater to retirees and an aging population. That does
not help the steel mill worker. They would have to be
retrained."
The steel industry is amid a restructuring as plants try to
survive the tough times, created by increased costs and competition
from overseas.
After the last week's developments, including the rejection of a
proposed 10 percent pay cut by the union, negotiations with
potential buyers and talk of another bankruptcy, it's unclear what
will happen to Georgetown Steel, which employs nearly 500 people.
It's one of the county's largest employers and highest
taxpayers.
In Georgetown and other steel towns, rumor mills are running
nearly as fast as the steel mills, generating talk of more layoffs
or a complete shutdown - actions that have happened at other steel
plants.
That's put leaders on alert to the crippling effect a potential
closure could have on area businesses and government budgets.
In Weirton, "Everyone is concerned ..." said Ed Powell, president
of the Weirton Area Chamber of Commerce. "In the long run, I think
we will be OK. There are a lot of things people are working on that
will help fill the void [if the plant closes]."
In South Carolina, officials in Gov. Mark Sanford's office said
they don't know what else they can do, beyond the package of
incentives rejected by the workers Wednesday, to help Georgetown
Steel keep operating. Other legislators said they, too, are at a
loss.
The cities' perspective
On Thursday, Weirton Steel Corp. officials said assistance from
West Virginia would play an integral role in the company's plan to
emerge from bankruptcy. The company has asked the state to guarantee
$18 million of a $175 million loan that is essential for the steel
company, officials said.
Meanwhile, the city of Weirton is trying to find money to plug a
$1.4 million hole the mill's struggles have left in the town's $12
million annual budget.
City officials in Georgetown also are dealing with a deficit
caused by the mill's decreasing equipment value.
They are considering cutting jobs, reducing garbage pickup to
once a week and closing the Police Department at night.
More-detailed talks will happen next month.
As they struggle to fill their own voids, cities also are trying
to help the mills.
Like Georgetown is considering, Weirton gave the plant a deal for
payment in lieu of taxes to help the mill. But Weirton Steel filed
for bankruptcy in May, and the city is one of those owed money.
Although new fees are unpopular politically, Weirton city leaders
are eyeing them to generate more revenue and are turning toward
tourism to offer a longer-term solution. A 1994 decision allowing
gaming helped the tourism offerings grow.
Gaming is booming in Weirton's county, Hancock County, and some
officials are hoping to expand on that gaming growth by bringing in
table games. Petitions are circulating to get the legislature to
allow a local referendum on the issue.
"This has certainly become an economic linchpin for our county,"
said Tamara Pettit, public relations director at Mountaineer
Racetrack and Gaming Resort, which is promising 400 new jobs if
table gaming is allowed. "They very much need the jobs."
Weirton's payroll has dwindled to 3,500 workers, with a cut of
another 935 jobs recently announced.
Some Georgetown officials, business owners and residents have
also talked about the need to expand tourism, which has upset those
who believe the mill is vital to the area's future because it pays
higher wages than the service industry.
An entire industry strained
The financial woes and job loss at Weirton, Georgetown and
Keystone Steel & Wire Co. in Bartonville symbolize the problems
that have strained the industry in the past few years.
Cheaper prices for steel made overseas, combined with rising
costs for scrap and natural gas, have squeezed domestic steel
manufacturers, which can't make steel for the price overseas
competitors are charging.
Also, manufacturing jobs worldwide are disappearing as
technological advances continue to increase productivity, meaning
fewer workers are needed.
Since 1998, nearly 40 steel companies have filed for bankruptcy
protection.
Some have merged with bigger corporations to give them the large
backing to survive. Others are trying to reorganize, relying on help
from local and state governments.
The number of jobs at Mountaineer resort has more than quadrupled
in the past nine years, jumping from 342 in 1994 to 1,700 now.
Weirton Steel's payroll went the other way.
The city is cutting costs by nixing capital projects, not
allowing overtime for city workers and scrutinizing cell phone
bills.
Miller, Weirton's mayor, is hopeful that will leave the city in
good financial shape through the end of this budget year, on June
30.
"After that, it is going to be very difficult," said Miller, who
retired from Weirton after 43 years. "We are making contingency
plans right now."
An uncertain future
Miller's counterparts in Bartonville are doing the same thing in
the shadow of Keystone, the area's largest employer, with 1,500
workers.
But Bartonville Mayor Marcia Markwalder is optimistic that growth
in stores and banks will keep the village of 6,300 people doing
well. A welding school is expanding, she said.
With rumors of a possible merger or a plant shutdown swirling,
Markwalder planned to bring up potential ways to help the mill
during a coming meeting with a state senator.
"It's been a little touch-and-go," Markwalder said. "Everybody is
watching their money. It is hurting."
Last week as Georgetown Steel workers weighed temporary pay cuts,
County Council tried to help by approving on first reading a plan to
give tax breaks to companies that invest at least $10 million in the
county and hire more than 200 people.
Mill owner Daniel Thorne has said he was looking for a buyer to
invest in the plant and keep it operating. But since the union's
"no" vote Wednesday, Thorne hasn't publicly commented about his next
move.
As steel towns look for something to replace the declining steel
industry, residents and leaders are clinging to the hope that the
mills won't go away.
S.C. legislators, as well as officials in Sanford's office, have
tried to create financial aid packages that would help Georgetown
Steel survive.
State leaders in West Virginia and Illinois have lobbied for
federal help, including tariffs President Bush imposed in March
2002.
"I would never count Weirton Steel out," said Mountaineer's
Pettit, who worked for Weirton Steel for eight years. "They are very
resilient. But it is a very, very scary time right now."
COMING MONDAY:
Closing of Georgetown Steel plant would strain
nonprofits.