South Carolina has
done its part to encourage at least one business
activity: Cigarette smuggling.
Thanks to North Carolina, South Carolina now
has the lowest cigarette tax in the nation. North
Carolina had held that distinction, but in
September raised its 5-cents-a-pack tax to 30
cents. The tax will increase to 35 cents in July
2006.
Meanwhile, South Carolina's cigarette tax
remains steady at 7 cents a pack, the nation's
lowest and 25 cents below the Southeast average of
32 cents a pack. That makes the state a natural
destination for cigarette smugglers.
Traffickers in cheap smokes can load up a truck
with cartons of cigarettes purchased in South
Carolina and drive them to New York, where the
sales tax on a pack of cigarettes is $3. A
thousand cartons from South Carolina sold in the
Big Apple could bring profits of nearly $30,000.
South Carolina doesn't affix tax stamps to
cigarette packs. State officials say the stamps
are expensive and don't benefit the state. But
that also makes this state's cigarettes more
attractive to smugglers. They can simply glue on a
counterfeit stamp in the state where they are
unloading the cigarettes.
New York and some other Northern states,
including Michigan, Pennsylvania, New Jersey and
Maryland, are trying to reduce the illegal trade
in cheap cigarettes. But enforcement is difficult
and, as law enforcement officials note, cigarette
smuggling can be safer and more profitable than
drug trafficking.
Perhaps it's understandable that South Carolina
officials have little desire to expend limited law
enforcement resources to help another state curb
cigarette smuggling. And, as S.C. Revenue
Department Director Burnie Maybank notes, the
purpose of tax stamps is to "make sure taxes are
paid in South Carolina, not to protect higher
taxes in New York state."
Nonetheless, the inequity of South Carolina's
cigarette tax with others in the region and, more
markedly, in other parts of the nation indicates
that the state's cigarette tax is too low. It's
not only the lowest in the nation but also well
below cigarette taxes in the region.
The state could be collecting more from smokers
and putting the money to good use. One idea,
mentioned frequently over the years, would be to
devote money from a higher cigarette tax to
boosting the state's share of Medicaid funding.
That, in turn would bring in more federal matching
funds, which contribute $2.25 for every dollar the
state puts in the kitty.
As an added bonus, studies have shown that
higher cigarette taxes reduce smoking, especially
among young smokers, who usually have less money
to spend on cigarettes. In other words, hiking the
cigarette tax could contribute to a healthier
population in several ways.
South Carolina doesn't have to raise its
cigarette tax to New York levels. But, come next
summer, South Carolina's cigarette tax will be 28
cents lower than North Carolina's.
That offers ample leeway to raise the tax, help
South Carolina's neediest citizens, perhaps reduce
cigarette smuggling -- and still maintain one of
the lowest cigarette taxes in the nation.
IN SUMMARY |
Cigarette smugglers love South Carolina
because of its lowest-in-the-nation tobacco tax.
|