DURING HIS ill-fated run for governor in 1974, Pug Ravenel called
the South Carolina General Assembly a "den of thieves."
Overly harsh? Of course. Unfair? Absolutely. Yet in some ways,
based on what we've seen in recent days, he was overly
optimistic.
Thieves, as contemptible as they are, at least exhibit such
useful traits as initiative, flexibility, daring and the ability to
make up their minds about what to do, and go ahead and do it.
Our Legislature, as a group, is utterly lacking in those traits,
all of which are sorely needed in this budget crisis. And it appears
that our governor, Mark "Bermuda" Sanford, is no Ali Baba
himself.
We are witnessing a descent into madness. Our government is
failing us utterly. The foolishness on display is beyond words,
beyond satire.
Consider:
• They can't bring themselves to
pass the cigarette tax hike, even though most people want it. Even
though it would provide a permanent funding source for medical care
for the poor -- something that the temporary infusion from
Washington announced on Friday won't do (an infusion that, by the
way, our lawmakers can take no credit for). The Republicans won't go
for it because it's a tax increase. The Democrats won't go for it
because there's a future tax decrease attached (one that wouldn't
kick in for five years). The governor insists upon the promise of a
tax decrease. He says he can't get the package through the House any
other way. The House won't pass it without the tax cut because the
governor says he would veto it. Ready to tear your hair out yet?
• Senators decided, suddenly and
utterly without warning, to call an official halt to the educational
progress we've made in the past five years by gutting the body in
charge of reform, the Education Oversight Committee.
• We now have a consensus between
the House and the Senate that we should set education back 25 years.
By reducing per-pupil funding to less than the inflation-adjusted
equivalent of the 1977 level, our "leaders" would take us back to
the days before we even tried to provide equality of educational
opportunity in our state.
• House leaders have been
whispering about a plan to replace some property taxes with
additional sales taxes, and in the process patching the huge hole
they have blown in school finances. But they won't do it. Why?
Because various narrow interests keep saying they don't like it.
Hey, I've got problems with it, too -- reducing the ability of local
governments to pay for schools is a huge step toward reducing local
control. But at least have the guts to bring the idea out so we can
talk about it. You don't have to get everybody to love it before
having a debate. Honest.
• What could be worse than
refusing to even debate that plan? I'll tell you: The Senate wasted
three hours Thursday debating a Bizarro version of it. This one
would have eliminated property taxes altogether, thereby turning the
state's tax structure inside out and basically eliminating the
ability of counties and cities to govern themselves. And what would
we get for that? About $58 million in extra revenue, bringing
per-pupil funding up to a little more than $1,700. The 1977 level
was, in 2003 dollars, more than $2,200. This is how they spend their
time.
• They can't bring themselves to
do away with the sales tax cap on cars, even though that is cited
most often by the average citizen as one of the really unfair things
in our whole tax system. Why not? Because car dealers don't like it.
Let's just move on.
• After initially failing to pass
a budget that met our minimal needs, senators said they would give
themselves three more days before giving up. They gave up after one
day.
They got disgusted, threw up their hands and went home. Well,
they should stay there, until they're willing to come back and get
serious. And when they do come back, they should stay until they
have passed a budget that meets today's essential needs and keeps
the promises we've made to our children's future.
Meanwhile, the governor took off to Bermuda. (Yes, I know he had
made a commitment to be there, and he was only gone one full day,
and he worked the phones while he was gone. He still shouldn't have
gone.) Here's hoping he returned with something he lacked before --
the will, the ability and the ideological flexibility to lead our
state, because the leadership certainly isn't coming from anywhere
else.
The Republican Party controls the State House -- the House, the
Senate and the governor's office. Republicans are no longer in the
position of back-bench bomb-throwers. They have to govern.
When you're out of power, it's all very well to pontificate about
keeping taxes low and stopping the "growth of government." Abstract
concepts are great; they're my stock in trade. But there's such a
thing as concrete problems.
And when you're in charge, you're faced with the unassailable,
ugly fact that in its entire history, this state has never provided
enough in the way of governmental services to give all of us a shot
at a life as good as what people enjoy in the rest of the country.
There's a reason why we're last where we want to be first and first
where we want to be last -- our government has failed us.
And now, thanks to our current Legislature and governor, we're
about to go backwards.
That would be just fine with some Democrats -- which is why some
of them have been refusing to negotiate in good faith -- but it
wouldn't be fine with most of us out here in the real world, dealing
with its real problems. I don't want somebody to blame. I want
somebody to fix this mess.
And there are no excuses for failing to do so.