Rep. John Graham Altman's intemperate remarks about domestic-violence
victims have triggered public condemnation that has been heard around the
nation. Ironically, his ill-considered words have virtually assured the
bill's passage, and sooner rather than later.
Though criminal domestic violence of a high and aggravated nature
(CDVHAN) already is a felony in South Carolina, criminal domestic violence
(CDV) that doesn't involve a weapon or serious injury remains a
misdemeanor for first, second and third offenses. After the House
Judiciary Committee rejected the CDV bill Tuesday while approving
legislation making cockfighting a felony, a Columbia television reporter
asked Rep. Altman to explain why the panel seemingly considered the latter
offense more serious than the former.
Rep. Altman cited problems with the bill that was rejected -- problems
that he was not alone in detecting. But his concerns that the bill
overreached were drowned out by a warranted outcry when he appeared to
blame domestic-violence victims for not fleeing from their abusers. In an
interview laced with demeaning comments about the intellect of the female
TV reporter, Rep. Altman said: "The woman [who is abused] ought not be
around the man. I do not understand why women continue to go back around
men who abuse them. And I've asked women that and they all tell me the
same answer, 'John Graham, you don't understand.' And I say, 'You're
right, I don't understand.' "
Rep. Altman also asked, "What self-respecting person is going back
around someone who beats them?"
Certainly Rep. Altman, who added that he didn't intend to blame abused
women for their plight, should now understand what a nerve he touched with
his insensitive comments. Abused women have numerous reasons for staying
with the men who hurt them. Among the obstacles blocking their exits are
concerns over money, children and their personal safety. Many women who
somehow summon the courage to leave so enrage their abusers that there are
deadly consequences.
South Carolina's high domestic-abuse statistics do demand tougher state
action against this crime. S.C. Attorney General Henry McMaster, over the
past two years, has enlisted private attorneys who volunteer to prosecute
CDV cases, providing more timely legal intervention against domestic
abusers in an effort to break the insidious cycle of escalating violence
as soon as possible.
After the Altman controversy broke, House Speaker David Wilkins issued
a statement that said: "In its present form, the bill has a number of
legal and technical problems that would have made it very difficult to
pass. We intend to fix those problems." The speaker and Judiciary Chairman
Jim Harrison also are preparing a bill that would make CDV a felony on the
third offense.
The pressure is on to address the problem and the Judiciary Committee
will make the bill a priority. That's a good result. Now let's hope the
legislators can debate the bills calmly and on their merits.