COLUMBIA, S.C. - State Supreme Court Chief
Justice Jean Toal breezed through a public hearing Tuesday on her
qualifications to serve 10 more years as the state's top judge.
Toal, 60 and the state's first female chief justice, answered
questions on topics ranging from her car accident involving alcohol
two years ago to her temperament toward lawyers and court
employees.
After the hearing, she said she was pleased and that things went
as expected. Toal, who sported a blonder hair color for the hearing,
joked that she was reading a legal brief while getting her hair
done.
She faces no opposition in her re-election bid, and questions
from members of the state Judicial Merit Selection Commission were
mostly routine.
The commission determines whether candidates for judgeships are
qualified and nominates them to the General Assembly. The panel took
no action Tuesday. Along with Toal, lawmakers also will elect a
Court of Appeals judge, 14 Circuit Court judges and 22 Family Court
judges in February.
Most on the committee seemed pleased with Toal's tenure as chief
justice.
"I do want to commend you for the last six years, you've been
exemplary," said Rep. Doug Smith, R-Spartanburg. "You've been an
asset to our state."
In 2001, Toal paid a $300 fine for leaving the scene of an
accident and driving too fast for conditions following a traffic
accident. She has denied that drinking played a role in the wreck
but acknowledged it was inappropriate behavior. Toal's car hit a
parked car and no one was injured.
"A person in my position should never be in a position to cause
there to be any question about their integrity," Toal said. "I have
renewed my commitment to this job. ... This has been a tough issue
for me, but you learn from every experience."
University of South Carolina law professor John Freeman said he
wasn't on the commission last time Toal was screened, but wanted to
point out there was no rumblings about Toal's temperament this
time.
During her associate justice re-election hearings in 1996, court
employees said Toal cursed around them or embarrassed them
publicly.
"I think that was a good wake-up call for me and a good learning
experience," Toal said. The chief justice said the commission could
ask judges and others anonymously about her temperament now.
"I think you would find that my demeanor and approach to both
staff and litigants has changed, and probably that screening had a
lot to do with it," Toal said.
Toal has been chief justice since taking over the term of Ernest
Finney, who retired in 2000. She became the first female justice to
sit on the state's highest court when she was first elected in
1988.
Toal also called for a commission to study issues involving
domestic violence and called for the General Assembly to look at
sentencing patterns for poor, minority defendants.
She said she was worried about the Family Court system because
there have been no new judges and the number of cases and their
complexity have exploded.
"We also have not been able to rotate judges, which is a great
management tool to put judges where they're needed," she
said.