Washington Gov. Mark Sanford and several congressmen are
decrying federal legislation they fear would usher casino gambling
into South Carolina.
The proposed bill, pushed by U.S. Rep. Jim Clyburn, would grant
the Catawba Indian Nation a high-stakes bingo hall in Santee.
But Sanford, and U.S. Reps. Gresham Barrett and Jim DeMint, worry
that the proposal would do more.
"My concern is that this bill could open the door for other forms
of gaming in South Carolina," said Sanford, a Republican.
Casino gaming includes generally higher-stakes gambling, such as
poker, roulette and blackjack. Casino opponents say such gambling
would tear at the moral fiber of the state.
"It preys on the less fortunate in our society, and I have major
concern with that," Barrett said.
In dispute is the intent of Clyburn's proposal. Why, casino
opponents want to know, does the proposal place the tribe under the
Indian Gaming Regulatory Act? That, they say, could make it easier
for the Catawbas to get a casino in the future.
Clyburn said the legislation is needed to allow the tribe to
build a second bingo hall in the state.
That's all it would do, said the Columbia Democrat, who sees
development of another Catawba bingo hall as a chance to bring jobs
and money to economically depressed Orangeburg County.
Clyburn has been circulating his proposal among members of
Congress, seeking their support.
Gilbert Blue, chief of the Catawba Indian Nation, said the tribe
is not aiming for a casino.
"Putting my honor on the line, there is nothing in this bill that
would give us anything but Class II Bingo," said Blue, referring to
the type of game the tribe is authorized to operate.
Robert Gip, a nationally known lawyer for Indian tribes who is
working with the Catawbas on the Santee project, said the law
forbids the Catawbas from building a casino.
Still, he said, he and others who crafted the proposed bill took
care to emphasize that point.
There can be no casino "without the consent of the state," Gip
said, pointing to a section of the proposed bill that excludes the
Catawbas from certain remedies under the IGRA.
Clyburn said U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham is working to help the
Catawbas in the Senate. But a spokesman for the Seneca Republican
said the senator is not involved in pushing legislation for the
Catawbas. Graham could not be reached for comment Friday.
Gaming has been a particularly difficult issue in South Carolina,
where strong coalitions of churches and politicians organized to
oppose and eventually kill video poker.
A 1993 agreement among the state, the federal government and the
Catawbas -- signed to resolve a dispute over ownership of tribal
lands near Rock Hill -- permits the tribe two bingo halls. The tribe
established the first in Rock Hill in 1997 and hopes to open the
second in Santee, off I-95 in Orangeburg County, in Clyburn's
district.
Clyburn said the tribe needs federal legislation of the sort he
has crafted to designate a piece of property in Santee as the second
hall location.
Concern has focused on a section of his 10-page proposal that
would place the tribe under the federal Indian Gaming Regulatory
Act, or IGRA.
Some who are uncomfortable with the proposal say giving the
federal government a bigger role in the Catawba gaming equation
could undermine the 1993 agreement that limited the tribe to two
bingo parlors.
Blue said IGRA offers the Catawbas some advantages in
establishing a second bingo hall. It would be easier, he said, to
bring the Santee land into federal trust, which would afford the
Catawbas tax breaks.
But casino gambling is not something the IGRA would allow the
tribe, he said, and building a casino could be negotiated only with
the state.
Still, Barrett, a Republican from Westminster, sees potential
trouble in the proposal. He said he first saw it Thursday
afternoon.
He said he sent the proposal to the Congressional Research
Service, the analytical arm of Congress, which pointed out "some
loopholes."
"If there's a provision in there that might potentially bring
full-blown casino gambling to South Carolina, I'm going to fight
it," Barrett said.
DeMint spokesman John Hart said the Greenville Republican has
"serious concerns with this legislation."
Clyburn said other tribes have the right to be governed by IGRA
and there is an element of prejudice involved in the worrying over
applying it to the Catawbas.
"If I was a Catawba, I would sue the state of South
Carolina."