Sanford may learn from Oklahoma's tax rebate problem
By JIM DAVENPORT,

(Published February 17‚ 2006)

COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) - Gov. Mark Sanford says he'll try to learn from problems facing some people in Oklahoma after that state shelled out tax rebates - and gave some people income tax headaches.

When Sanford unveiled his budget plan last month, he said the state was flush enough with cash to give taxpayers a $151 million tax rebate as part of a plan to control government spending. On Friday, with news the state's revenues are growing faster than expected, Sanford challenged legislators to put $237 million more into "dividends" for taxpayers that would amount to about $400 per family.

Reporting that kind of government giving on tax returns has become a problem in Oklahoma, which used $92 million in a rainy day surplus to give taxpayers income tax rebates. Most taxpayers received the rebates - $45 for single people and $90 for married couples - just in time for the Christmas shopping season.

It's tax season now and the rebates are creating an unintended headache for some people.

That's because the Internal Revenue Service will require people who may be accustomed to filing short paper tax forms, including the 1040-EZ, to use the IRS's longer and more complicated 1040 form.

The shorter forms don't have a place to report the rebate checks as income. People who received the money must report the income on the federal tax forms.

It's less of a hassle for people using electronic forms or tax preparers.

Sanford said Thursday he hadn't heard of Oklahoma's problems, first reported Tuesday in the Tulsa World. "Obviously this afternoon I'm going to become familiar with it," Sanford said.

"I would say there are wrinkles often times in any public policy," Sanford said. "The question is can things be done to fix it. Whatever caused things to go wrong in Oklahoma, I would bet that we could learn from that, rectify it and have a program that would work in South Carolina."

Sanford didn't commit to a specific way of issuing rebates when he rolled out his budget. Gubernatorial spokesman Joel Sawyer said "if the Legislature did agree with our idea we would look for a way to do this whereby we would avoid problems experienced by other states."

For now, legislators in a rush to approve property tax breaks have spent little time on Sanford's tax rebate idea.

Ways and Means Committee Chairman Dan Cooper, R-Piedmont, said Sanford's rebates aren't part of the budget that his committee begins discussing next week. If the rebates are discussed, it would be tough to come up with a way to deal with the problem Oklahomans face in reporting the rebates on federal returns.

"I'm at a loss to see how you get around IRS rules on that," Cooper said.

With Republican Sanford and the GOP-controlled House's 124 seats up for election this year, the proposal has fostered criticism.

For instance, the campaigns of Sanford's GOP primary opponent and Democratic challengers have called it an effort to buy votes or an election-year gimmick. Sanford says there's nothing political about the rebate plan.

Copyright © 2006 The Herald, Rock Hill, South Carolina