Cheaper S.C. health
plan considered State might allow
employees to opt for high-deductible, low-cost
insurance By JENNIFER
TALHELM Staff
Writer
The 350,000 South Carolinians receiving state health insurance
are about to see premiums increase by double digits for the fourth
year in a row.
But this year, there could be a twist.
The State Budget and Control Board is considering allowing
employees to opt for a low-cost, high-deductible health plan aimed
at making employees approach health care the way they consume other
products and services.
“With high deductibles, people will see the actual costs of
doctors visits and prescription drugs,” said State Health Plan
director Rob Tester. “The philosophy behind it is to make people
more active consumers and more careful consumers.”
The budget board — composed of the governor, the state treasurer,
the comptroller general and the chief House and Senate finance
committee members — will consider the proposal at their meeting
Tuesday.
Their decision — affecting almost one in 10 South Carolinians —
would take effect Jan. 1.
The rising number of retirees, combined with escalating drug
prices and health care costs, forced the state to come up with
$132.7 million more for health insurance for 2005.
The General Assembly contributed $13.4 million in the $5.5
billion 2004-05 budget, leaving employees to make up the rest. That
comes out to an average $38.80 per enrollee per month, either
through increased premiums or decreased services.
The proposal the budget board will consider would increase
standard plan rates by $16 to $40 per month, depending on coverage.
In addition:
• The annual deductible would
increase to $450 from $350.
• Prescription co-payments would
increase $2 per prescription.
• The state would stop covering
gastric bypass surgery, an expensive procedure chosen by 370 people
each year.
News that costs again will be passed on to employees and retirees
had some irate.
“Many of our members have worked for the state for very low
wages,” said Kent Phillips, president of the Association of S.C.
State Retirees. “They always said to us, ‘Don’t worry, you’ll get
good benefits,’ and now we’re seeing the good benefits slide away
from us.
“I have to tell you, we’re not real happy with what’s going
on.”
The high-deductible health plans and health savings accounts —
initially suggested by Gov. Mark Sanford — likely will be the more
controversial proposal for board members.
The new high-deductible plans would replace the “economy plan,”
which had slightly lower premiums but were used by only 6 percent of
employees.
The plan would cost $9 monthly for an individual or up to $108
for a family, compared to $85 to $275 in the standard plan.
Employees also would be responsible for the first $3,000 of routine
medical care.
Employees who opt for the high-deductible plans would be able to
create tax-favorable savings accounts to use for medical
expenses.
Tester said he did not know how many people would take advantage
of the new plan.
Sanford began the discussion about the high-deductible plan and
savings accounts out of frustration with increasing premiums and
what he saw as a lack of choice in the State Health Plan.
“The governor believes ... giving state employees more choice
will lead to lower costs,” said Sanford spokesman Will Folks.
“That’s what happens when you inject a market-, as opposed to a
government-driven, dynamic into a situation.”
But not everyone on the budget board is convinced.
State Rep. Bobby Harrell, R-Charleston, chairman of the House
Ways and Means Committee, said he looks forward to learning more
about the plan in a conference Monday with staff members.
State Treasurer Grady Patterson said he was not ready to comment
because he had not made up his mind whether to vote for it.
“The state treasurer is trying to make a decision that places
less of a burden on the backs of the employees of South Carolina,”
spokesman Trav Robertson said.
Reach Talhelm at (803) 771-8339 or jtalhelm@thestate.com |