Farmers in
California report that millions of pears are rotting on the branch
and that 30 percent of this year's multimillion-dollar crop will be
lost.
Why? Because there are not enough workers to pick the crop, and
farmers say that Congress' failure to approve a program to allow
immigrant workers to enter the country on a temporary basis is part
of the reason.
Congress, in fact, has declared immigration reform a dead issue
for the few weeks that remain of this session before lawmakers
return home for the final stretch of the fall campaign. Earlier this
year, it appeared that Congress was poised to pass comprehensive
immigration policy reform. But the effort ran aground when
hard-liners in the House could not reach a compromise with senators
on a balanced bill.
The Senate had produced and passed legislation that addressed
both issues of border security and the need to set a path to
citizenship for illegal immigrants now in the country. The Senate
bill received strong bipartisan support as well as the support of
President Bush.
But the House bill focused solely on border security, including
calls for fences along the border, funding for more border patrol
agents and punishment for illegal immigrants now living in the
United States. House members refused to consider proposals to allow
foreign workers to work here legally or a plan to allow illegal
immigrants to earn citizenship.
This week, as Congress reconvened, Republican leaders announced
that they have all but abandoned a broad overhaul of immigration
laws. Key lawmakers said they now believe it would be politically
risky to try to advance an immigration bill that would showcase
divisions within the party.
The irony, of course, is that Bush made immigration reform a
priority during his first term and lobbied hard for the Senate
version passed this summer. The president even devoted an entire
prime-time address to the need for reforms.
We think the measure supported by Bush and members of both
parties in the Senate was a rational bill that struck a balance
between enforcement and extending citizenship. While the supporters
of security-first try to paint themselves as the realists in this
debate, the opposite is true. The United States does not have the
technology or the manpower -- or, more importantly, the will -- to
completely seal off the border with Mexico. Nor does it have the
means or desire to deport 12 million illegal immigrants already
living here, often as productive members of their communities.
Republican leaders may be politically savvy in deciding not to
address immigration reform during the waning days of the session.
But they do the nation a disservice by failing to deal with one of
its most pressing issues. And make no mistake, it is the hard-line
House Republicans who are the obstructionists in this effort.
The rotting pears in California are only one example of how this
nation relies on immigrant labor. Congress needs to deal with the
reality of the situation, not some fantasy of sealed borders and an
America with no illegal immigrants.
IN SUMMARY |
GOP leaders in Congress decide that tackling immigration
reform is too risky.
|