Story last updated at 6:58 a.m. Wednesday, February 19, 2003 House panel advances bill outlawing executions of
mentally retarded
Associated Press
COLUMBIA--The House Judiciary Committee
approved a bill Tuesday banning executions of the mentally retarded.
The bill would require a pretrial hearing to determine mental capacity
if the state filed notice of intent to seek the death penalty. The
defendant would have to inform the state 30 days before the trial if he
intended to raise the issue of mental retardation, said Rep. Jay Lucas,
R-Hartsville, the bill's sponsor.
The court would then hear expert testimony and consider evidence of
mental retardation.
If the defendant were mentally retarded, it would be declared a
non-death penalty case, and a convicted defendant would be sentenced to
life in prison or at least 30 years, according to the bill.
If not found mentally retarded and a jury convicted, lawyers could
still present evidence to the jury on whether the defendant had mental
retardation.
The jury would then be asked to render a special verdict, answering
whether they found beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant was not
mentally retarded.
If the jury determined the defendant was mentally retarded, the
sentence would be a minimum of 30 years.
Observers say the bill could affect at least 10 of the 71 inmates on
South Carolina's death row.
Defense lawyer John Blume said the bill, if enacted, "would be clearly
constitutional."
"This seems like it would be a wise course," Blume said.
"The advantage is they don't run the risk in a few years of the Supreme
Court striking it down."