Exodus of officers
batters Patrol, SLED Low pay drains
state’s 6 key law enforcement agencies By JOHN MONK News Columnist
Budget cuts are crippling South Carolina’s six top law
enforcement agencies as hundreds of officers quit for better-paying
jobs elsewhere.
As state law agencies shrink, South Carolina is becoming an
increasingly friendly place for lawbreakers, including speeders,
illegal truckers, reckless boaters, wildlife poachers, prisoners and
ex-convicts on parole.
“The chances of getting caught for speeding in South Carolina may
be among the lowest in the nation, given their low number of
troopers,” said Tom Crosby, spokesman for AAA Carolinas.
“That’s accurate,” said Highway Patrol Col. Russell Roark.
Added AAA’s Crosby, “When miles driven continue to increase, and
law enforcement continues to decrease, it’s a recipe for
disaster.”
The number of S.C. troopers has dropped to 812 today from 970
five years ago. Each year, the patrol loses more than 50 officers it
can’t replace because state budget woes have forced the Legislature
to cut money to all agencies. (It costs $4 million to train, equip
and buy cars for 50 new troopers.)
Many police officers in the state’s six top law enforcement
agencies are so underpaid that, after three years of layoffs and no
raises, they are leaving in droves, agency heads say. The officers
are finding better-paying, securer jobs elsewhere — often in local
sheriffs’ departments or federal law agencies.
The Highway Patrol and the wildlife officers of the Department of
Natural Resources — two agencies where the visibility of officers
helps keep order on roads and natural areas — are especially
hard-hit. But as summer starts — and millions take to the highways,
beaches and lakes — the number of these officers is the lowest in
years.
Meanwhile, state traffic deaths are 46 ahead of last year, up to
389. And, last year, drownings in rivers and lakes reached a
five-year high of 33.
Also, post-9/11, most state law enforcement agencies are being
required to take on additional duties with reduced staffs.
“We are maxed out,” said State Law Enforcement Division Chief
Robert Stewart, adding further cuts would take his 340-agent
department “below the basic” minimum for public safety.
However, Stewart said he doesn’t expect more cuts.
LEAVING THE HIGHWAY PATROL
The Highway Patrol’s Roark said many departing troopers are
seeking better-paying jobs elsewhere. They join federal agencies,
including the Secret Service and the Drug Enforcement Agency, he
said. Also, local police forces pay more than the Highway Patrol and
offer yearly raises.
“We had one (trooper) join the Greenville County Sheriff’s
Department,” Roark said with an air of disbelief.
Last year, he added, four troopers in Horry County left to join a
police department in Las Vegas, where they could earn $45,000 a
year. The starting pay for a South Carolina trooper is $24,586.
The exodus of state police officers to local police jobs is
reversing a longtime trend. Once, local police officers joined state
law agencies for better pay. Now, it’s the other way.
“The state agencies are losing, and we are gaining,” said
Richland County Sheriff Leon Lott. In the past year, Lott has hired
about a dozen state law officers — including SLED laboratory experts
and Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services agents — in
the past year.
“I never thought I would see this day,” said Lexington County
Sheriff James Metts, who has hired 13 law officers from state
departments in the past year.
“We’re getting the cream of the crop,” he said.
Many state police feel insecure working for the state, Metts
said. In addition to no pay raises, there is job insecurity, created
as state agencies terminate workers to avoid raising taxes.
Richland and Lexington counties offer substantially more in pay,
benefits and job security than many state law agencies, Metts and
Lott said.
“Most are looking for a more stable job environment and better
benefits,” said Metts.
In Lexington County, the starting salary for law officers is
$28,906 to $31,000 a year, depending on education and experience. In
Richland County, the average starting pay is $25,510 to $28,749.
Most state law officers, except for SLED agents, start at less
than $25,000.
The hardest-hit state law enforcement police are conservation
officers, who work for the Department of Natural Resources. The
number of DNR officers, who enforce, fish, game and wildlife
regulations and boating safety, has dropped 31 percent, to 197, in
the past five years.
The DNR officers patrol the state’s lakes, rivers and coastline,
as well as other natural areas.
“We are doing more with less,” said DNR Capt. Harvin Brock.
For example, officers in DNR’s Region 3 in the Midlands patrol 12
counties, seven rivers — the Edisto, Saluda, Savannah, Broad,
Wateree, Santee, and Congaree — and two lakes, Marion and Murray. On
given summer weekends, these waterways have thousands of
boaters.
Five years ago, the region had about 60 officers. Now, it has
about 40.
An increased officer presence helps ensure people obey boating
and outdoor regulations, Brock said. “It’s like seeing a patrol car.
When you see that, you tighten up a bit.”
‘YOU CAN’T KEEP CUTTING’
Outsiders who work with state law enforcement agencies worry
about state staff cuts.
“It’s getting to a dangerous level,” said Lott, whose force works
with several key state law agencies. “You can’t keep cutting and
cutting and expect us to have a safer state.”
“This is the worst I’ve ever seen it,” said Sixth Circuit
Solicitor John Justice, who has been prosecuting criminal cases in
Lancaster, Fairfield and Chester counties for 26 years.
Justice said the troopers in his circuit have been cut in half —
in both the time they spend on the road and in court — and that
means the roads are more dangerous.
“There is a substantial number of people who obey the law only
because they see troopers out there,” Justice said.
The prosecutor said the Legislature should spend more on law
enforcement. “The Legislature has got to make public safety the
moral equivalent of national defense,” he said.
But attempts to get more money for law enforcement haven’t gotten
very far in the General Assembly. The state budget has been tight in
recent years, and many lawmakers want to cut taxes instead of
raising them to pay for law enforcement.
Gov. Mark Sanford, who was not available for an interview, is
“concerned” about low law enforcement staffing, particularly in
Corrections, a spokesman said Friday. In the wake of recent lean
budget years, Sanford is exploring ways to increase efficiency in
government, as well as changes to the tax structure that would
stimulate the economy and bring in more revenue, the spokesman
said.
House Speaker David Wilkins, R-Greenville, said raising law
enforcement salaries will be one of the House’s top priorities next
year. He said indications are that the economy is recovering and
more money will be available.
But the AAA’s Crosby said raising certain taxes offers a way to
raise money for better law enforcement. “These are things that we
have all come to expect for our tax dollars,” he said.
If South Carolina needs more money, it could add a few pennies to
its gasoline tax for more troopers, he said. Recent gas hikes have
shown people will pay more per gallon for gas, he said.
Each penny added to the gas and diesel fuel tax brings in about
$30 million to the state treasury, according to the S.C. Department
of Transportation. Currently, South Carolina has a 16-cent-a-gallon
gas tax — one of the nation’s lowest.
But state Sen. David Thomas, R-Greenville, a Senate Finance
Committee member, said the General Assembly “isn’t in the mood” to
increase taxes after three years of recession.
Politics aside, the General Assembly’s unwillingness to pay more
for law enforcement shocks many.
“I never thought I would see law enforcement and public safety
being cut because of budget concerns,” said Metts, who has been a
sheriff for almost 32 years. “There’s no price you can put on public
safety.” |