For sale by state:
178 prime city acres State Hospital
tract likely to lure developers By JEFF WILKINSON Staff Writer
A proviso deep in the state’s $5.5 billion budget is sending
developers and politicians scrambling to get ready for one of the
most anticipated and significant land deals in Columbia history.
Gov. Mark Sanford and the General Assembly agreed this week to
sell the 178-acre central campus of the State Hospital on Bull
Street — property assessed at about $32 million.
The tract is eight times larger than the old Central Corrections
Institution property being developed on the Columbia Canal. It is
the last and largest tract of urban land available in the capital
city.
“We would like a shot at it, and so would our competitors,” said
Stewart Mungo, of Mungo Homes, one of the area’s largest residential
developers.
Several other prominent local developers didn’t return telephone
calls about the property. Insiders say the magnitude of the project
and the payoff it represents have the region’s biggest firms playing
it quiet.
But Ike McLeese, president and chief executive of the Greater
Columbia Chamber of Commerce, says the land is a hot commodity.
“Interest is very high,” he said. “This is about the largest
piece of property to come available in the urban area any time in
the foreseeable future.”
The race kicked off when Sanford announced he would like to see
the huge tract and its roughly 50 buildings sold this year, with the
proceeds going to help the state’s ailing treasury. But the campus
will not be an easy turn.
The oldest building on the campus, the Mills Building, is not up
for sale, but its classic style should set the tone for the
redevelopment, preservationists say.
Restoration of the historic Babcock Building, with its
distinctive red cupola, is estimated at $20 million alone. Other,
newer buildings are filled with asbestos, which means developers
would face an expensive removal process if they want to reuse the
buildings.
“The problem with this property is it’s not residential or
commercial, it’s both,” Mungo said. “Very few people do both things
well.”
The cost — not only of the land, but also of demolition of newer
buildings and the restoration of historic ones — would be
prohibitive, which could limit the number of firms that could tackle
redevelopment, he said.
Another question to be resolved is the demand for the property,
he said.
“It’s a lot of money, that’s the biggest thing,” he said. “And
how deep is the market?”
The proviso also has city leaders ramping up to build zoning
grids, historic overlays and design guidelines in advance of the
sale. They want to ensure whatever is built, renovated or razed fits
with the historic in-town neighborhoods of Cottontown, Waverly and
the Mills District.
“It’s the most significant (development in decades) because of
its size and the timing,” said City Council member Anne Sinclair,
who once lived in the historic Mills Building as a caregiver.
“The economy is on the upswing,” she said. “There’s a lot of
interest in downtown Columbia, and people are paying attention to us
as a community. The timing is right. We want to be ready.”
But the size of the tract and the challenges involved have some
developers worried.
Mungo advocated breaking the property up into smaller parcels to
sell. “Otherwise you’ll just end up with some national company, a
Wal-Mart of developers, and the money won’t stay in the
community.”
McLeese said some local firms, such as Edens & Avant, Lake
Carolina developer Don Tomlin, and Mungo, would have the resources
and expertise to handle the entire tract.
Other, smaller firms could band together to take on the project,
he said. “In today’s times, a lot of people find ways to do things
together.”
Efforts to reach Tomlin, Edens & Avant’s John Lumpkin, and
Arnold Properties’ Ben Arnold were unsuccessful.
Another option, McLeese said, would be for the city to buy the
property, and then re-sell it as it did with the CCI site.
“But if that happened, they should immediately turn it over to
developers” to avoid the delays experienced at CanalSide, he
said.
Developers had been slow to embrace the CCI site because of tight
city design and zoning requirements, and delays dealing with the
Prison Industries Building, which the city tried to market for
re-use as a hotel. It since has been demolished.
Mayor Bob Coble said the city won’t purchase the property.
“The private sector is red hot, and it will develop that
property,” he said. “In the past, if the city didn’t step in,
nothing happened. But all we’ve done in the last 10 years has led to
a market where the private sector is able to develop properties like
that.
“But we want to make sure it’s done in a manner that’s consistent
with the surrounding neighborhoods.”
PUSHING FOR SALE THIS YEAR
When the property will be sold is still being hashed out.
The General Assembly this week passed the proviso state budget
giving the State Budget and Control Board authority to sell off
numerous properties around the state deemed surplus.
The State Hospital property was at the top of the list.
The proviso doesn’t direct the five-member board to sell the
property, but gives it the option along with the option of selling
other properties.
However, Sanford, the chairman of the board, wants the property
sold this year to put the estimated $32 million in proceeds against
the budget deficit.
Several factors could delay the sale: the size and price of the
property; the challenges presented by existing buildings; and, the
willingness of other board members to sell it quickly.
Because of those complications, “I think it’s highly unlikely it
can be sold this year,” Sinclair said.
But Sanford says it’s doable.
“The governor has been in the real estate business, his chief of
staff is a real estate lawyer and they both are confident they can
get this done and done quickly,” spokesman Will Folks said.
The governor is just one vote on the board, which includes state
Treasurer Grady Patterson; Comptroller General Richard Eckstrom;
House Ways and Means Committee chairman Bobby Harrell, R-Charleston;
and Senate Finance Committee chairman Hugh Leatherman,
R-Florence.
Spokesman Michael Sponhour said the board has yet to discuss the
property. “But the sooner we get the process rolling, the
better.”
The proviso doesn’t become law until July 1, and the board could
not take up the matter or even schedule a meeting until after that
date.
Sponhour said it’s too early to decide whether the land will be
sold as one tract or broken up into smaller parcels.
“Obviously our staff will bring forth a recommendation,” he
said.
MIXED USE, GREEN SPACE, MIXED INCOMES
Though the state owns the Bull Street property, the city sets the
zoning, historic protection and design rules for anything within its
limits.
On May 12, the council chose a committee of city staffers to
examine the qualifications of 24 consultants who want to study and
make recommendations for the property.
That committee is supposed to make a report to City Council on
July 1.
Sinclair said it’s too early to determine what the mix of
commercial and residential zoning will be or what buildings might be
protected.
“That’s what the consultant is for,” she said. “But I envision
mixed use — a live-and-work kind of environment.
“We are not trying to hamstring anyone. But we want it compatible
with the surrounding neighborhoods.”
Cottontown, just across Bull Street, will be the most heavily
affected neighborhood.
Already, Elmwood Avenue, which ends at the State Hospital’s front
gate, is one of the busiest streets in South Carolina. Residents
fear a 178-acre development across the street could make traffic
unmanageable.
“My preference would be for a mixed-use development with plenty
of green space, friendly to pedestrians and bicycles as well as
vehicles,” said Cottontown Neighborhood Association board member
Carol Hall.
“And, please, mixed incomes. Columbia is too segregated by
income.”
Reach Wilkinson at (803) 771-8495 or jwilkinson@thestate.com |