Lawmaker wants
low-performing schools to require uniforms
Associated
Press
COLUMBIA, S.C. - Lexington Rep. Tedd Pitts has
sponsored a bill that would force children who attend poor
performing schools to wear uniforms, but Pitts' proposal has drawn
resistance from educators and other lawmakers.
The Republican said Tuesday during a House education subcommittee
meeting that the mandate is not intended to be punishment for the
students. He said uniforms are intended to keep students focused on
school and less on fashion.
Pitts' proposal calls for a uniform dress requirement if a school
receives an annual or "absolute" rating of below average or
unsatisfactory two years in a row on state report cards. There are
about 144 of the state's 1,132 public schools that fell into that
category in the past two years, said Sandy Smith, the House
education committee's research director.
Five subcommittee memebers hesitated to endorse the proposal
Tuesday, but did not rule out giving the bill a favorable report
later.
Pitts told the panel he came up with the idea during National
Guard exercises in Texas last summer. He said he visited a
department store with a prominent display advertising clothing that
met local school uniform policies. He said he quizzed shoppers about
the rules.
Rep. Bob Walker, who chairs the subcommittee, said he needed more
time to look for research that might bolster Pitts' proposal, and he
was concerned there were already guidelines in place to help
low-performing schools.
"I have a problem with us mandating certain things," said Walker,
R-Spartanburg.
Educators said decisions about school uniforms should come from
the local level.
Rep. Michael Anthony, D-Union, said he was open to the idea but
he had concerns the Legislature might be usurping local school board
authority.
The South Carolina School Boards Association also said the bill
raised a red flag. "It might be a stigmatizing element to put
something in place," said the group's chief lobbyist Scott
Price.
Dillon School District 2 Superintendent Ray Rogers said he
understands uniforms have made a difference in a lot of areas, "but
I don't know that would necessarily hold true in every
situation."
At least one Columbia elementary school is in its first year of
an optional dress code that strongly encourages students to choose
attire from a recommended list.
Lonnie B. Nelson Principal Martha Roberts said the program had
widespread support among parents who answered a survey a year
ago.
"So far, it has gone nicely," Roberts said. The only complaint
was about the choice of white shirts that seem to get dirty quickly
when children are on the playground.
"Some parents do 'opt out' due to personal reasons," Roberts
said. "We certainly support their choice."
|