COLUMBIA--Even before lawmakers began their
debate on the state budget, Gov. Mark Sanford called a press conference to
outline exactly what he believed they should do.
Spelling out his priorities, the governor said the Legislature should
curb new spending, primarily directed at education and raises for law
enforcement officers, and dedicate more money to restoring trust funds
raided in lean budget years.
From the back of a room full of reporters, the House leadership waited
nervously to see what farm animal Sanford would haul out to attack them
with this time.
"We wanted to find out first-hand what the dispute was," House Majority
Leader Jim Merrill, R-Daniel Island, said. "It is important for us to hear
out of the governor's own mouth what he is going to say to the press."
The honeymoon is long over, and many Statehouse observers say the
General Assembly and the governor these days are in bad need of marriage
counseling.
Lawmakers complain the governor never talks to them directly, choosing
instead to govern by press release and issuing mandates via TV news. When
Sanford issues a statement to the media, there is often a response from
lawmakers, including one recently that, with a note of sarcasm, pointed
out the House was in "heated agreement" with the administration.
The dueling press releases have become something of a soap opera,
particularly given Sanford's flamboyant style of getting his message
across -- carrying a pair of pigs through the Statehouse last year to rail
about pork barrel spending and using a horse and buggy last month to
criticize the state's 19th century government structure.
In a phone interview Friday, Sanford explained that his is a
"transparent personality." He said he says what he means, praises where
praise is deserved, and pushes to make as many changes to state government
as he can. He said it would be impossible to talk to 170 lawmakers
individually before every decision, and uses whatever means he can to get
his message out.
The governor said he isn't slick enough to "to say nice things to your
face and then stab you in the back."
"It is just direct communication. It's important to say where we agree
and where we disagree," the Republican governor said.
That may be, but Sanford's frankness on the television news grates on
some lawmakers.
"I find his stunts quite amusing, because I think on some levels we
take ourselves too seriously up here," says state Rep. Gilda Cobb-Hunter,
D-Orangeburg. "But the leadership is not amused. He plays to the public
instead of the General Assembly, and perhaps that's why he's so popular.
But I don't think he's going to have much success getting anything done
that way."
Perhaps most surprising is that Sanford mostly raises the ire of his
own party. The House's Republican leadership in particular has taken
offense at the governor's criticism of a lack of action on restructuring
after lawmakers had passed as much of it as they felt they could get
support for.
"They try to work with him," Sen. Robert Ford, D-Charleston, said. "It
looks like he's always fighting the Republican Party even though they do
what he asks. They think he's crazy, attacking the folks looking out for
his agenda. I think it is part of a master strategy. No one is that
inept."
Legislative leadership is slightly more diplomatic.
"I don't think there's any doubt the governor could make it easier on
himself by improving his communication skills with the Legislature,"
Merrill said.
Most times, lawmakers bite their tongues, grumbling and grousing in
dark corners of the Statehouse. After the horse-and-buggy affair, however,
House Speaker David Wilkins publicly ridiculed the press conference.
Wilkins said he preferred to discuss differences over the phone rather
than "going to the farm and grabbing the first animal you can get."
Last week, Wilkins said he thought the relationship was "better than it
was" and noted Sanford attended a caucus lunch.
"You can get more done when you talk one-on-one with folks," Wilkins,
R-Greenville, said. "Ninety percent of everything we do is about
relationships. You don't vote against your core beliefs, but the most
effective members are the ones who have good relationships."
Sanford's office notes that lawmakers are warned of what's coming.
Weeks before the governor's budget press conference, he sent letters
saying much the same thing to every lawmaker. The day before the press
conference, the governor's staff went over budget issues with the
Speaker's office and the Ways and Means committee staff.
Sanford spokesman Will Folks said the House leaders were invited to the
press conference. They say they asked to come.
At the heart of this conflict, some lawmakers say, is that Sanford has
unrealistic expectations of how quickly the government can be moved, how
hard it is even for the party in power to ram major changes through the
General Assembly. By constantly beating dead horses -- or hiring live ones
-- he marginalizes his bully pulpit.
The state budget was a case in point. Last Tuesday, the House passed
its version of the 2005-06 spending bill unanimously -- an unheard of
accomplishment in the highly partisan chamber. Democrats say the House
Ways and Means Committee and its chairman, Charleston Rep. Bobby Harrell,
put together a fair, inclusive budget that was more in line with South
Carolina's needs than the governor's spending blueprint.
State Rep. Harry Ott, the House Majority Leader, said the governor is
clashing with his own party not so much because of political stunts but
philosophical differences.
"It's easy for someone who's always been rich to not understand why
some people need help from the government, but I believe the Republican
leadership understands this, and the budget reflects it," said Ott, D-St.
Matthews. "The governor isn't a Republican, he's a Libertarian and his
goal is to eliminate as much of state government as he possibly can."
Sanford said much of the bristling at his style is that it points out
what lawmakers are doing to their constituents.
"There are going to be disagreements if you push for change," Sanford
says. "I think it's incumbent for the administration to stand up and say
where we are in a public setting. It's nothing personal."
Most lawmakers would agree that Sanford is getting a little more savvy
in the ways to salve political wounds. Today, he will hold a bill-signing
ceremony for changes in the state's tort laws in Wilkins' district, a
courtesy the governor's office said is a direct thank-you to the speaker.
No animals are expected to attend.