McMaster’s comments
concern some activists
By CLIF
LeBLANC Staff
Writer
Attorney General Henry McMaster said Wednesday that black women
are more likely than whites to be victims of domestic violence and
he is seeking federal money to combat the problem.
McMaster said an analysis of five years of SLED data from 1996
through 2000 found that non-white women are 2 to 3½ times as likely
to be battered as white women.
“What this means to me is that black women are calling for help
at a rate 2½ times that of whites,” McMaster told an annual meeting
of domestic violence activists.
McMaster’s remarks left some activists questioning the statistics
and worried that domestic violence — which they say cuts across all
racial, income and education lines — might become entangled in
racial politics.
Addressing those concerns, McMaster said, “This is ... the only
factual data that we have. People can draw their own conclusions
from that.”
McMaster’s office is seeking a $900,00 federal grant to hire
three full-time prosecutors in seven rural Pee Dee counties, most of
which are predominantly African-American. They would prosecute only
domestic violence cases.
“We’re going to go where we are called,” said McMaster, who was
honored at Wednesday’s annual meeting of the S.C. Coalition Against
Domestic Violence & Sexual Assault, an umbrella organization for
activists.
Andrea Loney, is a black attorney with the S.C. Centers for Equal
Justice who has worked in the domestic violence field 23 years. She
said she questioned the statistics.
“I’m concerned about putting a color on domestic violence,” Loney
said. “I don’t want us to take the view that it’s a problem over
there.”
Vicki Bourus, director of the statewide advocacy organization,
said she does not doubt McMaster’s commitment to fighting domestic
violence.
Yet, “we cannot allow this issue to become a racial hot button,”
said Bourus, who is white. “It has got to stay focused on domestic
violence.”
Reports from the state’s 19 shelters indicate that white and
black women seek help in proportion to the community in which they
lived, Bourus said.
Her experience indicates that black women might call police or go
to court more readily because they have fewer choices, she said.
Bourus and other advocates said white women, who tend to have
more resources to leave home or hire attorneys, would be less likely
to call police — which is the basis of the data McMaster used.
“That doesn’t necessarily translate into a worse problem for
them,” Bourus said of black women.
McMaster acknowledged the statistics do not account for victims
who did not report attacks.
Sandra Hickmon prosecuted domestic violence cases in Newberry,
Laurens, Greenwood and Abbeville counties for four years, until
2002.
Hickmon, who is black, said she saw more black women victims than
whites, even though the judicial circuit where she worked is
predominantly white.
But the explanation for that includes the economic status of the
victims as well as the different ways police handle domestic
violence calls involving whites or blacks, Hickmon said. They are
more likely to make an arrest in a black home, she said.
Nancy Barton is director of Sistercare, which serves women
victims in five Midlands counties.
Barton, who is white, worries that what McMaster said could be
misinterpreted.
“I have spent time trying to break the stereotype of what a
battered woman is,” Barton said. “What I know is that domestic
violence crosses all racial, economic, educational and religious
lines.
“I think it’s a sensitive issue,” she said. “I think people could
misconstrue his intention.”
Reach LeBlanc at (803) 771-8664 or cleblanc@thestate.com. |