Hunters might get
extended bear season Critics assail
plan to add 1 week for hunting, 6 weeks for training
dogs By SAMMY
FRETWELL Staff
Writer
Emily Moss shudders when she thinks about the bear hunters who
descend on her mountain valley each year.
For a week in late October, she is afraid to walk in the forests
near her home, worried she might be hit by an errant bullet. She is
disgusted by the drinking and partying she said occurs after bear
hunters set up camp.
So a proposal to allow more bear hunting has Moss seething.
An Upstate sportsmen’s association is backing a bill that adds a
week in December to the mountain-hunting season. The bill also would
allow six weeks in the fall to train bear-hunting dogs in the
woods.
State wildlife officials and some bear hunters — who say the
sportsmen are well-behaved — contend there are more than enough
black bears to withstand additional hunting in the southern
Appalachian Mountains.
“This is a mountain heritage,” said Robert Chapman, president of
the Upper S.C. Bear Hunters and Houndsmen Association. “We’re not
out to annihilate the bear.”
But to Moss, more bear-hunting would mean more disruption in the
placid Eastatoee Valley of northern Pickens County. She’s primarily
upset about the huge parties of sportsmen who roam the hills,
hunting bears with dogs.
“Party hunts create an atmosphere conducive to drinking, possibly
while driving, all while carrying firearms,” Moss said in a recent
letter to state lawmakers.
“That week is an awful week for the sane and sober residents of
the valley, and we do not need any more like it.”
Plans to add to the bear hunting and dog training seasons have
caused a furor in other circles, as well.
The Humane Society of the United States says the sport is cruel,
unnecessary and unfair to the shy and elusive black bear —
particularly when dogs are used. Often, hunters use electronic
tracking collars to keep up with their dogs, and then they shoot the
cornered bears.
“It is just a trophy hunt, where they are after a head or a
hide,” Humane Society president Wayne Pacelle said of bear hunters.
“For a lot of people, this raises more ethical questions about the
suitable treatment of these animals.”
Pacelle’s group has fought attempts to allow or expand bear
hunting in states across the country. South Carolina should take
particular note, he said, because it has a low population of black
bears for a state that allows hunting.
The latest state estimates put the number of bears at 900 in the
S.C. mountains. North Carolina has 4,000 mountain bears, and Georgia
has 1,200, according to the S.C. Department of Natural
Resources.
Hunters such as Richard McAdams of Easley also oppose the bill.
He has hunted bears but was so upset about the bill that he helped
create a Web site — http://www.scbear.org/ — to fight
it.
The Web site says the use of dogs to stalk and kill bears “is
already out of control” because it is unfair chase and dangerous to
residents near hunting grounds. McAdams said the limited S.C. bear
population can’t withstand a big increase in hunting.
MORE KILLING OK
Supporters of the legislation say people should not be concerned.
They say the bear population appears to be on the rise.
“I have no doubt there are enough bears” to expand the hunting
season, said Skip Still, a Department of Natural Resources
biologist. “We support this kind of thing when the resource can
stand it. We’re pro-hunting.”
The agency estimated the mountain bear population at 450 last
year, but recently revised that to 900 based on its research and
that in neighboring states. Studies at the University of Tennessee
lend support to the higher number, experts say.
Since 2000, hunters have shot and killed more than 200 bears in
S.C. mountains, according to the Department of Natural
Resources.
A record 55 bears were killed in 2003. The 34 bears killed in
2005 represented the third-highest harvest since 2000, the agency
reports.
Bear hunters say they just want more time to practice a
tradition, as well as to train their dogs.
South Carolina’s bear hunting season now is confined to the last
two weeks of October. Bears can be hunted only in Oconee, Pickens
and Greenville counties. It is illegal to hunt bears on the coast,
where a small population exists.
The first week allows “still hunts,” or stalking and killing
bears without the help of dogs. During the second week, sportsmen
can use dogs to track bears.
Under legislation sponsored by Rep. David Hiott, R-Pickens, South
Carolina’s bear-hunting season would include a week in December.
Three days would be for still hunts and four days for dog hunts,
which draw most of the opposition.
The bill also would allow hunters to have their dogs chase bears
through the woods at night for six weeks, beginning in September, to
train them for the actual hunts. The new rules would apply only in
the mountains of Oconee, Pickens and Greenville counties.
Supporters note other states, such as North Carolina, have longer
hunting and training seasons.
The S.C. legislation isn’t close to passing; it remains in a
House of Representatives subcommittee.
ROWDY DEBATE
Chapman, who once lived in the Eastatoee Valley, said the bear
hunters association is willing to drop the extra time to shoot bears
to get six weeks to chase bears as training.
But even that has opposition.
McAdams and Pacelle said bears can overheat and die when chased
long distances.
Chapman and Hiott said bear hunters are not rowdy drunks. Most
who camp in the Eastatoee Valley are well-behaved and respectful,
Chapman said. The Department of Natural Resources reports no undue
problems with bear hunters.
“Ninety-nine percent of our people are church-going people,” said
Chapman, 55, who has hunted bears since his childhood. “We’re for
preserving game. That’s one reason you see more bears than in the
past.”
Moss remains skeptical. She said she can’t take an expansion of
either the dog-hunting season or the running season for bear
dogs.
On many days, the crackle of gunfire and the baying of hounds
disrupts the solitude near her mountain home. The Eastatoee Valley,
off S.C. 11, is a scenic bottomland ringed by the mountains of the
Jocassee Gorges nature preserve.
Said Moss, “I feel like I have a piece of paradise here, except
for that one week — when I have a ticket to hell.”
Reach Fretwell at (803) 771-8537 or sfretwell@thestate.com. |