As a top-ranking official at the U.S. Department of Transportation,
Jeff Shane ought to be publicly ducking the Dubai ports controversy.
Instead, the attorney and DOT undersecretary for public policy said he is
tickled by the political firestorm that has spread in recent weeks.
"I'm like the guy chewing on Chicken McNuggets," he said Wednesday in
remarks at The Citadel. "I'm lovin' it."
Shane, an appointee of President Bush, wasn't being disloyal to the
White House, which has been roundly criticized for approving the sale of
six U.S. port terminal operations to a United Arab Emirates company
without notifying Congress. His point was that the fracas has fixed public
attention on the nation's underfunded and increasingly congested
transportation network.
Before the Dubai Ports World flap, Shane said, the "vast majority" of
Americans had "no clue" about how ports work and the critical role they
play in the movement of goods in and out of the country. "They don't see
them. Stuff just shows up on the shelves," he said. "And it's a good thing
it does, because we love having it."
Now, lawmakers and the public alike are getting a quick lesson about
where the waterfront fits into the global supply chain, thanks to the
debate over whether
Dubai Ports World should be allowed to take over the U.S. business of a
British company, Peninsular & Oriental Steam Navigation Co.
"That's why I'm so pleased we have controversy in Dubai World," Shane
said at a luncheon sponsored by the Charleston-based Free Enterprise
Foundation. "People are discussing it."
The controversy has helped give the public a better understanding of
global trade, he said. For instance, Shane was delighted to see that The
Washington Post recently published a detailed illustration of how a
typical container port operates.
"This is to die for," he said. "I couldn't have possibly come up with
anything like that."
Shane hopes all the attention will prompt lawmakers to address what he
described as an alarming problem within his agency: Funding for critical
transportation projects is being "completely overwhelmed" by federal
entitlement programs.
"In a good year we're keeping ourselves flat," he said of DOT.
Shane said complaints about transportation bottlenecks are piling up in
his office, but not from just the usual suspects, such as airlines,
shipping lines and trucking companies.
"Something new is happening . The users of transportation are coming
in," he said.
Dell, Nike and Liz Claiborne are among the companies worried about
congestion at the nation's ports, roads and airports hurting their bottom
line, Shane said.
"What I'm saying . is transportation is embedded in the fabric of the
U.S. economy in ways we've never seen before," he said.
Shane said one possible solution is for the United States to step up
the privatization of its transportation network, as other countries have
done. "The private sector has a much bigger role to play than ever
before," Shane said.
As the Dubai controversy illustrates, privatization can also have its
drawbacks. For the record, Shane echoed the White House response to the
deal, saying "it doesn't have any impact that we can see on security."
"If you're buying a terminal operator . for $6.8 billion, a terrorist
incident is probably the last thing you want to happen on one of your
ports," he said.
Reach John McDermott at 937-5572 or jmcdermott@postandcourier.com.