Makeup of adoption
panel draws fire Conservative group
assured of seat on committee to study adoption by gay or unmarried
couples By JENNIFER
TALHELM Staff
Writer
S.C. gay and lesbian activists are angry that a conservative
Christian-interest group could be included on a state committee
studying adoptions by gay and unmarried couples.
A bill before the state Senate would make the Palmetto Family
Council the only private group guaranteed a position on the study
panel. No professional social science organizations or gay and
lesbian groups were named to the committee.
The Palmetto Family Council is a nonprofit group that advocates
for traditional families and opposes gay marriage.
Gay and lesbian activists say putting the group on the committee
stacks the deck against nontraditional families.
“It doesn’t make sense that they’re the main opposition (to gay
adoption) and they get a seat on the committee,” said Johanna
Haynes, S.C. Equality Coalition chairwoman. “We’re hoping that would
be reconsidered and we would at least get a seat at the table,
too.”
Sen. Mike Fair, R-Greenville, the bill’s sponsor, said he didn’t
know how the Palmetto Family Council got on the study committee and
he would consider removing the group.
Fair said he would have to think about having a gay and lesbian
group sit on the panel because, he said, their behavior is not
condoned by most South Carolinians. “That gives them a legitimacy
that society and South Carolina says isn’t acceptable.”
In its original form, the bill prohibited gay or unmarried
couples from adopting or becoming foster parents.
State Sen. Maggie Glover, D-Florence, added the requirement that
the two-year study by the committee also be done, though it wouldn’t
delay the law taking effect if passed by the Legislature and signed
by the governor. Glover said she didn’t ask to include the Palmetto
Family Council on the study committee, either.
Glover opposes Fair’s bill partly because, she said, it would
limit the pool of potential foster or adoptive parents.
Because the bill is opposed, it’s unlikely to pass the Senate
this year.
But Oran Smith, president of the Palmetto Family Council, said
his group is working to get the bill passed.
Smith said he would welcome help on the committee from a gay and
lesbian group. He said the Palmetto Family Council is opposed to any
unmarried couple — gay or straight — adopting a child.
“I think we need to protect our children from modeling that
behavior,” Smith said.
Fair agrees.
He said he has seen cases in which children were harmed by
parents in nontraditional relationships.
“If you have two competing interests, is it the safety of the
child or the sexual freedom of the adult which is the most
important?” he said. “To me, it’s clear. It’s the safety of the
child.”
Gay and lesbian activists say that ignores many studies showing
that children thrive in nontraditional families.
They say that is why it is so important for them — or at least an
unbiased social scientist — to be included on the committee.
“It’s not a political thing; it’s about families,” said Warren
Redman-Gress, executive director of Alliance for Full Acceptance, a
gay and lesbian advocacy group in Charleston. “It’s a study
committee, it’s not a lunch group.”
Reach Talhelm at (803) 771-8339 or jtalhelm@thestate.com. |