The truth has a biological advantage. It doesn’t need the
artifice of man to survive. It lives and breathes freely on its
own.
Seventy-eight-year-old Essie Mae Washington-Williams recently
confirmed one of the oldest rumors of Southern political folklore:
that she is the mixed-race daughter of former Sen. Strom
Thurmond.
Williams, whose mother worked as a maid in the Thurmond family
home, was long rumored to be Thurmond’s daughter. In a 1968 book,
writer Robert Sherrill alleged that Thurmond had fathered a
mixed-race child. In 1972, the front page of a local South Carolina
newspaper announced that Thurmond fathered a “colored offspring.” In
1992, The Washington Post referred to Williams as Thurmond’s
“supposed daughter.”
During the senator’s lifetime, Thurmond’s family and staffers
repeatedly denied the claim, describing Williams as a friend of the
family. Through my long working relationship with the senator, I
know otherwise.
There was a conversation that occurred at a 1996 Washington Urban
League ceremony honoring myself and Sen. Thurmond for the growing
bonds between black and white Americans. Back stage, Sen. Thurmond
leaned over and said, “You know, I have deep roots in the black
community — deep roots.”
His voice softened into a raspy whisper: “You’ve heard the
rumors.”
“Are they just rumors, senator?” I asked.
“I’ve had a fulfilling life,” cackled Thurmond, winking
salaciously.
The subject came up again while the senator and I were attending
a S.C. State football game in Orangeburg. He mentioned how he had
arranged for Williams to attend S.C. State College while he was
governor. (Sen. Thurmond caused a stir when his official car rolled
onto campus for a visit.)
“When a man brings a child in the world, he should take care of
that child,” said Thurmond, who then added, “she’ll never say
anything and neither will you — not while I’m alive.”
Thurmond showed me where she lived while attending S.C. State and
admitted to helping her out financially. Though he didn’t say
outright that Williams was his daughter, the senator’s remarks left
little to interpret.
Then there was a private conversation we had a few years back.
The senator had been frequently ill at the time and given to random
bouts of nostalgia. He mentioned how proud he was that he was able
to maintain a close relationship with Williams.
Beaming with pride, he talked about how she called him and
sometimes took him to task when she didn’t agree with statements he
made. Perhaps he saw some of his own tenacity reflected back in her.
Thurmond also talked about the disconnect between what politicians
sometimes espoused publicly during the de jure segregation era and
what they did in their private lives.
This point was not lost on civil rights leaders, who collected
pictures of Williams on campus to use as political ammunition
against Thurmond, a noted segregationist at the time.
But Williams never confirmed the rumors. For 78 years, she
honored the senator’s request that no one know the truth about their
relationship. During his lifetime, she placed the senator’s
political career above her own well-being. So why is she coming
forward now?
Williams has not made any financial claims on Thurmond’s estate.
“We are not looking for money. We are merely seeking closure by way
of the truth for Essie Mae Washington-Williams,” said her attorney,
Frank Wheaton, to The Washington Post. After nearly eight decades of
subverting certain basic and essential facts about her identity, it
seems that Williams wishes to be honest with herself — and society —
about who she is.
This is a good thing. Now that the senator’s personal
indiscretions can no longer be used against him, there is a moral
obligation to set the historical record straight.
After all, the history of Sen. Thurmond is inextricably bound up
in the story of Southern politics. In 1954, he became the first
person elected to the U.S. Senate by write-in vote. His 24-hour
filibuster on a 1957 civil rights bill still ranks as the longest
speech ever on the Senate floor. In all, Thurmond’s political career
spanned seven decades, making him the longest-standing public
official in our country’s history.
The senator’s story is our history. Now that Sen. Thurmond has
passed on, history deserves a full accounting.
Mr. Williams, a native of Marion, hosts “The Right Side with
Armstrong Williams,” a nationally syndicated talk-radio
program.