S.C. GENERAL
ASSEMBLY
Defeat of Put Parents in Charge troubles
GOP
LEE BANDY
For S.C. House Republicans - in need of a come-to-reckoning
meeting - today's caucus meeting couldn't come too soon.
Ever since members voted to kill GOP Gov. Mark Sanford's top
education issue in 2005, strains have emerged within the state's
governing party.
There are threats of retaliation at the polls, name-calling and
general harassment.
"Oh, my gosh, you wouldn't believe it," said state Rep. Gene
Pinson, R-Greenwood. "This thing has been so divisive it has
splintered the caucus."
At issue is the May 4 defeat of the Sanford-backed Put Parents in
Charge tuition tax credit proposal.
The governor put his political prestige on the line for the bill
and lost, thanks in part to 18 caucus members who voted to kill the
plan and three others who took a hike.
The defeat wounded the governor and caused a rift in the
caucus.
"Yes, there is a strain," said state Rep. Joan Brady, R-Richland.
"Right now, it's very uncomfortable."
"It's the most divisive thing I've seen since I've been here. And
I don't like it," said state Rep. Skipper Perry, R-Aiken, who was
absent the day of the vote. "Both sides need to get over it."
The battle was hard-fought on both sides. A lot of blood was shed
and left on the floor.
Members told of phone calls and e-mail messages from voters, some
laudatory, some not so polite.
"People did not like losing," said state Rep. Dan Cooper,
R-Anderson. "Education is a highly emotional issue. And people were
sharply divided. There was some name-calling mostly aimed at those
of us who didn't vote for the bill."
House Majority Leader Jim Merrill, R-Charleston, worked around
the clock to line up support for the measure, causing some members
to squirm. They fretted about getting caught in the cross hairs of
the majority leader and his team of lobbyists.
State Rep. Bill Sandifer, R-Oconee, said most of the emotion was
stirred by outside groups, causing bitter feelings. "They tried to
make it that way," he said.
State Rep. J. Adam Taylor, R-Laurens, who missed the vote, said
supporters of the tuition tax credit bill hurt themselves by
constantly revising the proposal.
"They changed it so many times and had so many versions that it
confused a lot of people," he said. "Most couldn't tell you what was
in the bill."
Pinson is most concerned about how the dispute might affect the
caucus.
"This has been a very divisive issue, a polarizing issue. It has
caused a lot of ill feelings inside the caucus," he said. "If the
issue doesn't hurry up and heal itself, I fear for the future of the
caucus."
State Rep. David Umphlett Jr., R-Berkeley, thinks the whole
controversy has been blown out of proportion.
"Some people pushed hard, but nothing cracked. Things get that
way in close vote. The way I look at it, the vote has been taken.
That vote is over with."
Merrill acknowledged tensions still exist, but he said they are
cooling. "The bitterness the issue caused was to be expected," he
said.
"There's nothing more emotional than education. You could talk
about changing the color of ... school buses and people would be up
in arms."
Republicans remain divided. Relations with the governor are not
great. And there are growing strains within the state's governing
party.
House Speaker David Wilkins' personal popularity might be the key
element holding the GOP together. But he's bound for Canada as U.S.
ambassador once Congress confirms his nomination.
Contact Bandy, a political reporter for The
(Columbia) State, at 1-800-288-2727. |