COLUMBIA--The state's Education Department
might be able to save money by privatizing its school bus system, Gov.
Mark Sanford suggested during a recent budget hearing.
South Carolina is the only state in the nation that owns and maintains
its school bus fleet, education officials say. It's a costly effort that
requires millions of dollars for maintenance, replacement and staffing.
Next year, the Education Department will need $67 million more for its
transportation system, State Superintendent Inez Tenenbaum told Sanford.
That money would pay for bus repair and maintenance, new buses and other
equipment and increases in driver salaries.
Overall, the department says it needs more than $589 million more than
its current state funding in the next fiscal year. Most of that money --
$340 million -- would be used to help the state meet the $2,201 base
student cost that the Board of Economic Advisors has said is required
under a state school funding formula.
Sanford is gathering input from state agencies as he prepares his
executive budget.
A 1998 study by the Budget and Control Board found the state could save
as much as $250 million over a decade by privatizing its school bus
system, Sanford said.
Tenenbaum said a pilot run by school districts in Charleston and
Beaufort counties after the study was released showed no savings.
"Privatization is not going to save us any money," Tenenbaum said.
The school bus problem is a cyclical problem that has been popping up
since the 1980s, said Sanford's chief of staff Fred Carter. Changing that
will require creativity, he said.
"Our approach this time needs to be innovative," Carter said. "It needs
to be creative. This time we've got to take a different approach."
Tenenbaum says her agency looks forward to working with the governor to
come up with a solution.
Privatization, though, is no easy fix and poses a number of challenges
that rival current ones, education officials say.
Contracting with private companies could be costly because most would
require buses be replaced routinely and would pay mechanics more
competitive wages, said Education Department spokesman Jim Foster.
Many buses in the state-owned fleet are more than 20 years old, and
mechanics make $10 an hour.
Another challenge is that private companies are more willing to bus
students in urban areas where the routes are shorter than in rural areas,
Foster said.
Urban sprawl contributes to that problem, Sanford said. As students
move farther from the center, buses have to travel longer routes, he said.
About 335,000 students are transported to school each day on South
Carolina's 5,600 school buses.