FLORENCE — Lowering the state income tax is the key to
jump-starting a stalled S.C. economy, Gov. Mark Sanford said Tuesday
in announcing his new tax plan.
Keeping more money in taxpayers’ pockets will start “a virtuous
cycle” of small business growth, Sanford said from the construction
site of the future home of ACS Technologies.
Ten years ago the homegrown firm had about 30 employees. Today
more than 300 work for the company that produces software aimed
specifically at faith-based groups and churches.
“This is what we would like to see being created in so many parts
of South Carolina,” Sanford said.
The governor’s plan, which he’s touting in a three-day, 12-city
tour, would:
• Raise the tax on a pack of
cigarettes to 68 cents, up from 7 cents.
• Apply the state sales tax to
lottery tickets, meaning a ticket that now costs $1, could cost
$1.05.
• Use the new tax money to lower
the income tax rate to 5.9 percent, down from 7 percent, for those
who make more than $12,000.
Less than a mile from where the governor spoke, Kathy Ham was
worried Sanford’s plan was more nightmare than dream.
“They should leave the lottery alone,” said Ham, manager of the
Scotchman convenience store on David H. McLeod Boulevard. “The
lottery is supposed to be helping education. You’re going to drive
people away.”
Bonnie Elam, 52, of Creston in Calhoun County, smokes generic
brand cigarettes. She buys them at Native American reservations
where state taxes aren’t collected.
“I know we need to lower income taxes, but as far as raising
taxes on cigarettes? You’re punishing one category of people,” Elam
said.
She suggests instead raising the state sales tax on
everything.
Alonzo Garrett of Columbia is more worried about where the
cigarette tax money would go. The 42-year-old non-smoker said
raising the cigarette tax to fund health care would make more
sense.
Besides, he said, too many things are taxed now.
“There’s a tax on almost everything you purchase,” said Garrett,
who operates a stand selling T-shirts and CDs outside the El Cheapo
gas station on Percival Road. The whole point of the lottery, he
said, was to raise money for education. Taxing lottery tickets won’t
help that, he said.
But Sanford said it’s necessary to lower income taxes. He said
studies by the Beacon Hill Institute at Suffolk University in Boston
have shown that states that lower income taxes reap big economic
benefits.
Lowering the income tax would make South Carolina a “relatively
more attractive place to work and, therefore, invest,” said David
Tuerck, Beacon Hill director.
Democrats are worried that Sanford’s plan would leave Medicaid
without a stable funding source. They and several Republicans hope
to increase cigarette taxes to pay for Medicaid, which provides
health care for the poor and disabled.
The state needs an estimated $200 million for the 2004-05 fiscal
year for Medicaid alone. Sanford previously proposed using the
cigarette tax increase to pay for Medicaid, accompanied by a gradual
income tax reduction. But lawmakers rejected that plan last
year.
State Rep. Joel Lourie, D-Richland, said he’s surprised to see
Sanford “pull a 180” on the cigarette tax. “To see him abandon that
philosophy so quickly is a great concern.”
Reach Gould Sheinin at (803) 771-8658 or asheinin@thestate.com