JUST A FEW HOURS before lawmakers washed their hands of the
dangers to which they are subjecting our state, a State House
veteran noted that after a month of haggling, "both sides are
exhausted, and both sides feel like they're losing."
They're right. However you define the sides -- Democrats and
Republicans, senators and representatives, those trying to bail our
state out of its worst financial crisis in decades and those content
to sit on their hands -- they're both losers. And so are all of
us.
True, it's not as bad as it could have been. But that's no thanks
to our legislators. What glimmer of hope we have is thanks to the
Congress, which bailed out the Medicaid program by giving us enough
federal money so that we could keep paying doctors and hospitals and
pharmacies the insufficient amount we're currently paying them to
take care of the people who are too sick and too poor to pay for
their own care -- for one year.
There were even a few million federal dollars left to sprinkle
onto public education, so our per-pupil funding will be $1,701
instead of $1,643. But that's still $500 less than what is required
by state law -- a law that has been fudged over the years to hold
the number down artificially; it's less, in real dollars, than we've
spent at any time in the two and a half decades since we made a
commitment to educating all of our children.
SLED might not have to lay off any more agents -- although it's
already down about 60 -- thanks to a special surcharge on police
tickets that our "no taxes" Legislature had the good sense to pass.
The Department of Juvenile Justice might get out from under federal
oversight because it's getting part of the $25 million from that
fee, too. But both agencies, along with the Corrections Department
and the Highway Patrol, are at the breaking point. If anything
breaks badly in the next 12 months, we will have a crisis on our
hands.
Sort of like the crisis we already have on our hands with
dangerously mentally ill people who aren't getting the treatment
they need; if we're lucky, they'll just keep clogging our emergency
rooms, making true "emergency" care a roll of the dice for the rest
of us. If we're not lucky, they'll kill themselves and others.
Legislators say this is the best they could do under the
circumstances. It's not. Not by a long shot.
They could have increased the cigarette tax to the national
average, as three-quarters of us want, bringing in needed money and
reducing the number of kids who start smoking. They could have
raised other taxes.
But they couldn't raise taxes, they say. Let's pretend, for the
sake of argument, that this is a rational statement. Even if you
pretend that, this still isn't the best they could do. Not by a long
shot.
They could have done what every business, every non-profit, every
family does in times of financial crisis. They could have eliminated
the things that seemed essential until the crisis hit -- the
taxpayer-funded lobbyists, the jail cell for every truant and every
adult caught with drugs, the cost of running 85 separate school
districts and 33 separate colleges, to name a few. That would have
freed up money to spend on teachers and troopers and mental health
doctors and prison guards.
Yes, legislators set priorities. They said Medicaid is our top
priority. They said public education is next. But they only set one
more priority: They made it a priority not to make any difficult
decisions, not to do any hard work, not to put themselves out on a
limb. Not to save our state from crisis. And they did a remarkably
good job of meeting that priority.