GREENVILLE - South Carolina has lost
nearly 65,000 textile and apparel jobs in 11 years, so it's no
wonder Dick Gephardt boasts that he is the only Democratic
presidential candidate to oppose both the North American Free Trade
Agreement and relaxed trade rules for China.
Or that Democratic rival John Edwards stresses that he is the son
of an S.C. mill worker from Seneca. Or that Wesley Clark visited a
textile plant in rural Enoree to show support for workers in the
state, which holds a pivotal primary Feb. 3.
"Textiles went by the wayside when they started sending the
business overseas," says Tina Hester, who works in a memento-filled
church office in the old Union Bleachery mill village where she grew
up and her father labored for 40 years. "They couldn't compete."
A few miles away, a 9-year-old BMW plant represents the flip side
of global trade. About 4,700 employees turn out luxury automobiles,
more than half of which are exported for sale. Partly as a result of
their wages, Main Street sparkles downtown, and Starbucks recently
opened its first stand-alone storefront in the area.
Still, a Greenville Magazine poll last month found two-thirds of
potential voters in the state's open primary favor trade
restrictions to protect jobs. And with 60 textile plants closing
across South Carolina since 1999, the political opportunity is clear
for Democrats.
"I'd just like to see us use our economic might as much as we use
our military might," says Roger Chastain, president and chief
operating officer of Mount Vernon Mills. A lifelong Republican, he
says now, "I probably lean toward Gephardt."
South Carolina aside, manufacturing employment nationally has
declined for 40 consecutive months, a loss of 2.8 million jobs. With
the Bush administration struggling to fend off criticism, trade may
reverberate into the fall election in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Michigan
and elsewhere.
Additionally, Wednesday's announcement of a new Central American
Free Trade Agreement will spark a fierce battle in Congress. But
those events are months away. Already, the issue is critical in
South Carolina, and the Democrats are maneuvering for position.
Seven states hold primaries or caucuses Feb. 3, coming quickly
after early contests in Iowa and New Hampshire. South Carolina is
drawing attention as the first southern state to vote. It also is
home to a large number of blacks, and some officials estimate half
the primary voters will be black.
Edwards, a first-term senator from next-door North Carolina,
needs a win to sustain his candidacy. Retired Gen. Clark and Sen.
John Kerry of Massachusetts, a decorated Vietnam veteran, seek
affinity with the state's many military veterans.
Gephardt, the Missouri congressman who must win first in Iowa,
looks to South Carolina to help him emerge as the principal
alternative to front-runner Howard Dean.
"South Carolinians know what NAFTA is," says Danielle Vinson, a
political science professor at Furman University, referring to the
1993 pact that eliminated trade barriers with Mexico and Canada. To
be successful, she says, a candidate must use the textile industry's
decline "as a jumping off point to talk about jobs" in a state where
unemployment is 7.1 percent.
Gephardt, the former House Democratic leader, hopes to lay claim
to the issue.
"We're in a global economy. You've got to deal with it. You can't
just protect the United States," he says. He tells audiences that he
bucked a fellow Democrat, former President Clinton, to oppose NAFTA,
freer trade with China and other measures because they did not
require other countries to have meaningful labor and environmental
protections.
When Gephardt pocketed the endorsement of Rep. Jim Clyburn, the
state's dominant black politician, the campaign rushed out a TV
commercial touching on trade. "Together, we stood up for
middle-class families against NAFTA," Clyburn says.
Edwards, too, wants custody of the issue.
"Growing up, it seemed like almost everyone in town worked at the
mill. When it moved, it was devastating," he says in a commercial
with an old mill as a backdrop.
Now, he says, plants are "packing up and moving where labor's
cheap, and the environment doesn't count. It doesn't have to be that
way," he adds, pledging tax breaks for companies that build plants
in this country.
But Gephardt accuses his rivals of "11th-hour conversions ...
when it mattered they weren't there." As governor of Vermont, Dean
supported NAFTA and wrote Clinton a letter in favor of the China
legislation. Kerry and Sen. Joe Lieberman of Connecticut supported
both measures.
Gephardt has called Edwards a "Johnny-come-lately" to the cause,
noting his vote for the China trade deal that accelerated the
decline of the textile and apparel industries.
In response, a spokesman for Edwards says Gephardt voted for
legislation in 1991 that made it easier for presidents to pass trade
deals, and led to NAFTA's approval. "The congressman can be out
there picking and choosing his votes, or highlighting certain votes
and think that people are going to ignore others," said spokesman
Roger Salazar.
But in an interview, Gephardt mentions Pillowtex, an N.C.-based
textile maker that declared bankruptcy last summer with the loss of
more than 7,600 jobs. "It had a terrible impact on a big employer"
in Edwards' state as well as South Carolina, he says.