COLUMBIA -- A Lowcountry Republican
apologized Tuesday for offending people with
comments he made after he helped kill a criminal
domestic violence bill last week.
Rep. John Graham Altman's apology came as the
S.C. House put a reworked criminal domestic
violence bill on a fast track in response to
outrage about the Charleston lawmaker's remarks
after the House Judiciary Committee killed similar
legislation.
The new bill, like the old one, toughens
penalties for domestic abuse now classified as a
misdemeanor. That bill could be debated as early
as today on the House floor and go to the Senate
by the end of the week, said Rep. Gary Simrill,
R-Rock Hill.
Last week, Altman questioned the intelligence
of a Columbia television reporter who juxtaposed
the domestic violence bill with a bill making
cockfighting a felony that cleared the committee.
Graham also questioned why women return to abusive
relationships.
"I do not understand why women continue to go
back around men who abuse them," Altman said to
WIS-TV. "I've asked women that, and they all tell
me the same answer, 'John Graham, you don't
understand.' And I say, you're right, I don't
understand."
On Tuesday, Altman told the House he wanted to
express "regret, real regret, and real sorrow over
the publicity that this House has gotten in the
last week."
He said he "offended a lot of people -- and
some people I offended who I didn't offend, but
they're still offended -- and I just want to
apologize to each and every one. My intentions
were not, never have been, never will be, to paint
this institution or any of you in a negative
manner. ...
"I'm sorry I caused pain to those to whom I
really caused pain, and I'm sorry I caused pain to
those who might want to say ouch anyway."
House Speaker David Wilkins and Judiciary
Chairman Jim Harrison said Altman's remarks
sounded sincere.
Simrill called the remarks "unfortunate," but
said that they may have proved to be the catalyst
for getting new laws passed this year.
Rep. Joe Neal, D-Hopkins, said the apology fell
short because Altman apologized only for offending
people, not for his remarks or actions.
Altman would not respond to that.
His remarks came as Republicans rallied around
the new legislation -- and peeved Rep. Gilda
Cobb-Hunter, an Orangeburg Democrat who was the
lead sponsor on the bill that died.
Wilkins and Harrison thought they had
Cobb-Hunter on board with the new bill as its
chief sponsor. But she backed out Tuesday morning,
complaining about Republicans taking marquee roles
as co-sponsors, including Altman.
"I am not going to be a part of a Republican
whitewash. I am not going to be part of an effort
to clean up the Republican caucus problem,"
Cobb-Hunter said.
"What we're trying to do is pass a serious CDV
bill that strengthens the penalties, like she was
trying to do," Wilkins, R-Greenville, said in a
weekly news briefing sponsored by South Carolina
ETV and the South Carolina Press Association.
"Whether it's a Republican author or Democratic
author, I could care less. What I do care about is
getting this bill passed and sending a strong
message that we take CDV serious in South
Carolina," Wilkins said.
Peggy Payne, executive director of the local
Safe Passage women's shelter for abuse victims,
said she also didn't care which party sponsored
the bill.
"It's a bipartisan issue," said Payne, who felt
stronger laws against domestic violence should
have been passed earlier. "Sometimes progress is
slower than you'd like to see, but at least we're
making progress."
New bill's provisions
Under the new bill:
• The first conviction on criminal domestic
violence is a misdemeanor that can bring up to 30
days in jail and a fine up to $2,500. The current
penalty is 30 days in jail or a $500 fine.
• A second offense is a misdemeanor that brings
a minimum of 30 days to a maximum of one year
behind bars with up to $5,000 in fines. That's up
from the current penalty of 30 days and a $500
fine.
• A third offense would be a felony with one to
five years in prison. That crime now is a
misdemeanor with up to three years in prison.
Rep. Ralph Norman, R-Rock Hill, supports the
bill.
"They're wanting to strengthen the bill, which
I'm in favor of," Norman said. "I think it'll pass
pretty easily. There may be some amendments and
tweaking in different places, but I think it's
good."
While issues with the bill may be approaching
an end, Altman's problems may not be over.
For instance, the House Democratic Caucus
delayed calling for sanctions against him on
Tuesday. On Saturday, the state Democratic Party
called for Altman's resignation at the end of its
convention.
Wilkins says he has had several conversations
with Altman about those remarks, but neither will
talk about what was said, including whether
sanctions are being considered.
Harrison could remove Altman as a Judiciary
subcommittee chairman or from the committee
altogether.
Also Tuesday, protesters gathered across the
street from Altman's Charleston home to push for a
stronger criminal domestic violence law.
"Altman embodies the main problem in curbing
domestic violence by blaming the victim," said
Merrill Chapman, Charleston coordinator of the
South Carolina Progressive Network.
Herald reporters Jason Cato
and Matt Garfield contributed
to this report.
WANT TO GO? |
A domestic violence rally sponsored by the
South Carolina Coalition Against Domestic
Violence and Sexual Assault will be 1 p.m. today
on the north steps of the Statehouse in
Columbia.
|