New effort mounted
to delay school start 3 senators seek
late August date By CZERNE M.
REID Staff
Writer
Next year’s lazy, crazy, hazy days of summer could last a little
longer for students if three South Carolina senators have their
way.
Sens. Luke Rankin, Scott Richardson and Dick Elliott — whose
districts include coastal Horry and Beaufort counties — prefiled
bills in December to push back elementary and secondary school year
start dates to Aug. 25 or later for the entire state.
Rankin’s bill also calls for the year to end no later than seven
days after the last Palmetto Achievement Challenge Test in May.
South Carolinians who favor the bills say families are missing
out on making summer holiday memories and students lose the
opportunity to take summer jobs and earn money for college. In
addition, businesspeople say, when schools start early, the state —
and especially the coast — loses tourist dollars.
“It adds up to real big money,” said Elliott, a North Myrtle
Beach-area real estate developer specializing in vacation
rentals.
But school administrators and others say the state will lose more
than money if schools start later in the fall. Among other things,
students and teachers will come up short on Palmetto Achievement
Challenge Test instruction time, and time for teachers to prepare
lessons and meet with parents, they say.
Many educators say local school districts should be allowed to
set their calendars based on their own needs.
A previous late-school start bill pushed in 2002 by Horry County
legislators and backed by the tourism industry failed. To compromise
then, state Superintendent of Education Inez Tenenbaum pushed the
PACT tests back by a week, to the second week in May as of this
year. Still, most districts decided not to start school later.
The new filings come in the wake of similar North Carolina
legislation that passed last year and will take effect in 2005. Some
North Carolinians complain that legislators gave little
consideration to the impact on public schools and the communities
they serve. They say tourism interests poured money into the
campaign, successfully recruiting teachers and parents.
Dawne Wise, whose son Robinson is an eighth-grader in Richland 2,
said that when she was growing up, school started two days before
Labor Day and ended the first week of June.
“I really wish they’d go back to that,” she said. “Fall is when
you go back to school. Aug. 8 is not fall.”
Fourteen-year-old Robinson said he hates having to go back in
early August when it is still hot. He would prefer to vacation from
June to September rather than May to August, he said.
Although many parents want schools to start later, they agree
that a single start date across the entire state might not be
practical, and the decision is better left to local school
districts.
Whereas, for example, a late start would suit schools in Horry
County where tourism is the main economic activity, Richland
District 2 prefers an early start coupled with longer breaks at
Christmas, Thanksgiving and in the spring. That arrangement better
accommodates the district’s families, many of whom are affiliated
with the Fort Jackson military base, said superintendent Stephen
Hefner. Students often need to visit relatives overseas during the
fall and winter breaks.
“I think it’s a travesty that the tourism industry is guiding
what our schools do,” said Kathy O’Quinn, Richland 2 teacher of the
year. “It’s absurd.”
O’Quinn is a member of the district’s faculty advisory committee,
a group of teachers who put together the Richland 2 calendar. The
district is one of few in which teachers still have this
opportunity.
“We want the calendar that helps our teachers do their best work
and helps our students do their best work,” said Hefner, a member of
South Carolina Association of School Administrators.
Richland 2 schools will start on Aug. 8 this year — with
reason.
When the 1984 Education Improvement Act passed, start dates moved
up from September to late August. They moved up even more when the
state began requiring students to complete 24 academic units before
graduating from high school.PACT TEST A FACTOR
The Palmetto Achievement Challenge Test also drives school start
dates. Students must have at least 180 days of instruction before
the spring test, and complete testing early enough that the state
can send out reports by August.
“We need every day we can get to prepare for the test,” said
O’Quinn, who teaches music at Round Top Elementary.
Businesspeople and legislators say public education would get a
boost from the increased sales tax revenues that a later statewide
school start would bring in. And the good part is that other state
programs are not being cut to provide those extra funds, Elliott
said.
“It’s like mama sending you a check from home,” he said. “It’s
like a windfall.”
At least two studies were commissioned to look at later school
start dates:
• The state Department of
Education’s Uniform School Start Date Task Force was formed in
2002.
• A summer mail-in survey, paid
for by the S.C. Travel and Tourism Coalition and carried out by
Coastal Carolina University in 2004.
Both found the uniform date could generate more vacationers and
tax revenue. However, there were no guarantees.
Still, Dean said, the state would benefit from a later start
“window” that creates a bigger chunk of time for people to travel,
and at the same time gives schools limited flexibility.
That wiggle room is important for local school districts, said
Chuck Saylors, president of the South Carolina Parent Teachers
Association.
“A one size fits all answer may not be completely
appropriate.”
Reach Reid at (803) 771-8378 or czreid@thestate.com. |