H.L. HUNLEY Scientists try to keep preservation
simple Experiments, use of chemicals
could threaten historic submarine’s physical
integrity By JEFF
WILKINSON Staff
writer
NORTH CHARLESTON — The submarine H.L. Hunley sits
in a tall, blue tank at the Warren Lasch Conservation Lab, filled
with 45-degree water pumped in from the public water system.
No chemical soup. No scientific improvisation. No radical
experimentation. Just tap water.
Chemicals would have spoiled the remains of the Hunley crew.
Experimentation could threaten the physical integrity of the
historic vessel. So, for now, scientists want to keep it simple.
“You don’t want to do any ‘kitchen sink’ work here,” said the
Hunley’s senior conservator, Paul Mardikian. “You don’t want to
guess.”
When the Confederate pomp and circumstance of today’s burial for
the Hunley crew is over, what will remain will be the sub and the
science.
Preserving the 40-foot-sub is a challenge. Salt from 140 years of
sitting on the bottom of Charleston Harbor would slowly turn its
cast iron frame into rust if exposed to air. The chlorides must be
removed for the boat to be stabilized.
In the past, the only way to save such vessels from the ravages
of the sea was to disassemble them. Salt can effectively be removed
from individual pieces of metal by electrolysis. But removing it
from between riveted plates, or the intricate working of machinery,
has been difficult, if not impossible.
Disassembling the Hunley would require drilling out dozens of
rivets from its fragile metal plates and wrenching apart its
delicate moving parts. The cure could be worse than the disease.
“The question is whether you can put it back together again,”
said Michael Drews, a professor of material science and engineering
at Clemson University.
Hunley scientists say they are developing a groundbreaking
technique for removing the salts from the metal. But the method —
which involves a process called cold hydrogen plasma reduction — is
unpatented and uncertain.
“We’re still working on a solution,” Drews said. “We’ll find out
15 to 20 years down the road if we made a mistake.”
For now, they are tight-lipped on the details.
“The intellectual property isn’t protected yet,” Drews said.
The lab usually is only open on the weekends for tours. Visitors
watch videos about the ship’s recovery and conservation, see
scientists at work and view the boat itself.
But with about 20,000 people in town for today’s burial, the lab
has been open every day.
Up to 300 visitors have filed past the Hunley daily, paying $10
to see the first submarine to sink an enemy ship in combat. Most
also spend at least that much in the lab’s gift shop.
Hunley boosters and backers hope the stream of visitors continues
as more people learn about the project from today’s national press
coverage of the burial.
The sub is to be the centerpiece of a planned $40 million Hunley
Maritime Center to be built in North Charleston. The advancement of
the museum, as well as the advancement of science, depends on the
Hunley surviving its recovery.
The sub could be left soaking in a tank, but that would lessen
the visitors’ experience. The scientists’ aim is to stabilize the
sub so it can be displayed in open air.
But marketing is not their first concern. The Hunley team’s goal
is find a way to conserve not only their boat, but other maritime
treasures as well.
“Our job is to preserve things that were not meant to last
forever,” Mardikian said.
Reach Wilkinson at (803) 771-8495 or jwilkinson@thestate.com |