PEOPLE HAVE COME up with all sorts of proposals for getting South
Carolina out of our lingering fiscal crisis, from raising taxes to
eliminating agencies.
But there's a much less painful way: Make everybody pay the taxes
they owe.
It's truly that simple. Perhaps not easy, but simple.
Although we can't say for sure, there's good reason to believe
that if everyone in South Carolina paid the taxes they should, we
wouldn't have a budget problem.
The latest indicator of this came when the Multistate Tax
Commission reported last month that South Carolina loses an
estimated $80 million a year to corporate tax cheating and
sheltering, due in part to "structural weaknesses and loopholes in
the state corporate tax systems." That's a huge loss when you
consider that the state collects just $192 million in corporate
income taxes. It's an unacceptable loss when you consider that just
six states let more corporate tax revenue slip away.
But corporate tax sheltering is just one part -- and likely a
small part -- of our problem with people not paying their fair
share:
- Revenue officials say more than 50,000 South Carolinians who
should file state income tax returns don't. And thousands who do
file tax returns don't bother to pay the taxes they acknowledge they
owe, unless and until they get a knock on the door from a tax
collector.
- South Carolinians skip out on paying more than $200 million a
year in use taxes -- the equivalent of a sales tax -- on Internet,
phone and mail purchases.
- As many as 128,000 cars and trucks in the state aren't licensed
and registered, which means their owners aren't paying property
taxes on them.
We have nobody but ourselves to blame for the property tax
cheating; until earlier this year, our laws made it virtually
impossible to address the problem.
But Washington has played a part in the sales and income tax
problems.
The Congress is actively hindering our ability to collect sales
taxes on Internet and phone purchases, by prohibiting states from
treating them the same way they treat Main Street sales -- requiring
the merchant to collect the tax and send it to the government.
Further, the Congress has done nothing to change a tax system
that encourages income tax sheltering. And in recent years, the
Internal Revenue Service turned a blind eye to income tax cheating,
particularly among the wealthiest individuals and businesses. This
reduced the number of tax cheats who got caught by the feds, and
subsequently had to pay state taxes; and it emboldened even more
people to cheat.
The good news is that the IRS has begun to go after the
proliferating tax shelter industry.
The bad news is that South Carolina has done just the opposite.
As tax revenues in our state slumped, the Legislature actually
reduced the state's ability to collect taxes, by slashing the
Revenue Department's budget. The number of Revenue employees dropped
from 749 in 2001 to 563 at the end of last fiscal year. And that was
before its latest $2 million budget cut kicked in.
Revenue Director Burnett Maybank says that with another $10
million, he could catch $90 million in unpaid taxes; he even
promised to resign if he failed. There is every reason to believe he
would succeed: When legislators set aside $900,000 a year ago for
the department to rehire some of the auditors it had laid off, they
quickly pulled in an extra $20 million.
What's inconceivable is that legislators aren't willing to make
more of this sort of
investment.